Are you happy? Why are some people happy and others not? Is there a point to life? Is it worth all the effort? Is absolute truth a real thing, or is everything relative? How do you find truth? How do you know what to do with your life? What's the value of religion? How far should science be trusted? Can people be trusted? Is there any idea that could provide universal common ground? What would it actually take to achieve world [or even personal] peace?
At present, there are more than eight billion of us struggling with difficult questions like those, and in our efforts to work them out we drown ourselves in a rising sea of ideas—some entertaining, informative, or inspiring, and others extreme, emotional, or complete nonsense. Some of them can seem true at first, but don't stand up to logic, survive the test of time, or acknowledge exceptions. Even real truths are often isolated, individual nuggets of thought—cat posters, trite phrases, dead-end metaphors, and single-use slogans—rather than connected pieces in a larger picture.
At some point you graduate from those motivational cat posters and start considering the broader perspective. You begin to wonder what's actually true, and how those truths connect. If I've done it right, this book will describe the larger picture clearly enough for you to recognize where your collection of truths fits in.
This is a book about happiness, and you'd be justified in asking what qualifies me to tell anyone else how to be happy, but I'll consider myself justified in not answering that question, because this isn't a book about me or my opinions (if it were, it would be significantly longer). I'm keenly aware of the arrogance of writing a book like this, so I've tried to keep myself out of it. I don't need anyone to understand me, but it will benefit you to know what I know.
The world's current degree of misery proves that the principles in this book are poorly understood and desperately needed. They do pop up in bits and pieces here and there, but it's the general lack of awareness of the complete picture that concerns me—the fact that so many people are unhappy and don't appear to understand why.
Not having ever come across these ideas collected and organized logically, plainly, and succinctly, it seemed like something meaningful I could contribute. I don't pretend to have invented all these ideas, and I didn't even plan for most of you to read this. It was meant only for my family.
This book is essentially a collection of the most meaningful truths life has taught me—the reward of decades of difficulty and reflection. I was concerned I wouldn't remember it all, so I started writing, mostly for my own benefit. Then, seeing the unique value of those ideas when laid out and organized, I decided to turn it into something I could leave to my family, and by the time that was done, it was clearly of use (and hopefully value) to anyone.
This may not be an entertaining read, in the typical sense. It's not a novel, or your usual collection of inspirational stories, optimistic mantras, or supposed life hacks, and I hope it won't be seen as a philosophical thesis, either. This is a book about principles, which might sound a bit dry at first, but they're the framework of life—the logic behind happiness, and the why of everything. They're the most valuable kind of knowledge, but they take time end effort to understand and apply. This is the foundation. It's what you need to know first. And it's meant for those who crave happiness and truth, and are willing to open their minds and to change.
As books go, this one isn't very long, thanks to it containing only what I actually understand. Admittedly, the first chapter is a bit of a marathon, but it's critical to understanding the rest of the book, so hang in there.
And we'll start with a poem.
The Chest With a Hundred Locks
A treasure chest sat anchored far beneath a twisting tide;
Its siren song sang loud and strong of spoils held deep inside.
Through weary years I’d sought it out o’er seas of calm and storm,
While coral, clam, and barnacle disguised its ancient form.
Some seasons past, alone I’d sat and cursed an icy gale,
When a stranger’s voice, though old, soon pulled me in with an earnest tale
Of a roiling sea and a row toward shore, waves thrashing, tall and steep,
Then the ship broke, and the tide’s grip tugged fast into the deep.
In waning light their eye caught sight of an object in the sand,
So against the churn this stranger fought, and seized it with a hand.
A chest they’d found—fixed firm by time—then they quickly rose for air,
But eyed the shore and marked the spot, to seek the treasure there.
Outstretched they held a yellowed map, well worn from ocean faring,
Its sparse lines sketched where to find the shoreline and the bearing.
The chest, they said, held riches more than a single soul could spend,
So the map was mine, with a kindly nod, and I thanked my new-found friend.
Then time had past, as I rowed and dove, till pain gave way to pleasure,
And I found at last the blessed chest which held the ancient treasure.
That sturdy box, still mortared fast by crusted shells and rocks,
Had a rusty lid with a checkered grid—and a hundred simple locks.
Back home I rowed that night, with empty hands and troubled head.
No key was shared with the map…though, perhaps, I could make each one instead.
For a hundred dives I read each lock as long as lungs could stand,
And home I went, and months I spent molding key after key by hand.
Then I rowed and dove with cheer and hope and the heft of a hundred keys
To pull me straight to the chest where I sank on anxious hands and knees.
I swiftly worked, and jerked the lid when I’d turned the final locks,
And shimmering sand and bubbles swirled like gold dust ‘round the box.
But the chest was bare—no treasure there on its strangely polished base,
So I looked inside and all I saw was my hopeful, searching face.
Then a golden gleam ensnared my eye from the ancient, lifted lid—
A shining script, a gilded verse…the gift the old box hid:
“The cutting makes the statue, the blow forms the blade,
The furnace turns the clay to stone, the pressure casts the jade.
The venture makes the hero, and when the task is done,
It’s polished soul, not polished ore, that proves the prize was won.
This chest you’ve found, and deep inside are riches to behold—
A treasure sought, a treasure won, beyond its weight in gold:
A being now of greater worth, refined, with heart and steel.
Now go and send some hungry soul to seek what I conceal.”
…
A treasure chest with a hundred locks awaits below the sea,
It’s riches there for all who seek the wealth it brings to me.
So now I wait, and watch, and hope for souls who thirst for more,
A map to share, to guide them where the chest’s not far from shore.
Happiness is the purpose and highest state of life, the fundamental goal
of humanity, and the natural result of truth
and virtue. That may sound obvious, but it's not enough
to know or even agree with the idea—at least, not if the goal is to actually
increase your degree of happiness. For that, you need to understand and feel
that concept in all its important nuance (exceptions included). Hence, the rest of this book.
There
is method in the madness of life, and a simple, beautiful logic to the natural
laws of happiness. If you aren't as happy as you'd like to be, this can
help you understand why, and what to do about it. It may not make your
problems go away, but it will help you understand how to achieve happiness
in spite of them—and to some extent,
because of them. First, you need to understand what happiness
is, which starts with life itself.
Life
What makes you alive? What distinguishes life from something dead or inert?
Think about that for a bit and you'll probably arrive at some version of
"organized, self-directed, self-perpetuating, energetic growth." These
are some of the most basic and common traits of life, from single-celled
organisms to complex, intelligent species. They take in energy, perform
specific functions in a self-directed, self-motivated way, and usually
reproduce. More often than not, they're connected to other forms of life—both
taking and giving. They change, both individually and as a species, and
usually die. And even their death and decay provides the conditions necessary
for new life.
Atoms, minerals, planets and stars, viruses, and even human inventions
do
some of that, and it's helpful to view life as a spectrum rather than on or
off—a range of organization, complexity, connectedness, self-motivation, growth, reproduction,
and cognition that starts with inert matter on one end, moving up to the
most conscious and intelligent beings on the other. As you ascend that
spectrum of life those attributes increase—as well as a purpose to justify
the higher state of energy and use of resources.
Purpose
Cells would have no justification for living and consuming the resources
they do without a constructive purpose. The same goes for the structures,
tissues, and organs those cells create, as well as the being to whom they
belong. Function and purpose justify complexity and use of resources.
All life on this planet fits into some ecosystem: a specific environment
with resources that preserve life and allow individuals to fulfill a purpose
that contributes back to the system. Life almost always gives more than
it takes, and is more than the sum of its parts. This "circle of life"
symbiosis gives us a very simple sort of value and place in the world.
Like plants that grow toward the light that gives them energy, intelligence
appears to have produced an intrinsic pull in humans toward
our most energizing motivation—something more meaningful than our natural
function of predator, prey, or fertilizer. Consciousness makes us aware
that we're alive, aware of our state of being, and capable of thinking
beyond survival. Conscious, rational beings require purpose and meaning—to
understand
why (and anyone with a toddler can tell you that half-conscious, irrational
beings also want to know "why"). That motivation is happiness. And there's
a reason.
Happiness
To understand real happiness, start with something more familiar: misery.
When someone is miserable, what does that look like? What happens when
you experience absolute hopelessness, despair, guilt, worthlessness, and
anxiety? We usually pull inward, away from others, lose our motivation
to do anything, feel overwhelmed, close out the world, and surrender to
a crushing, paralyzing, numbing inner oppression that seems inescapable.
We become resistant to love or logic, sinking into a hole of reckless self-loathing.
Life is organization, self-motivation, energy, and growth. Misery is chaotic,
apathetic, tired self-destruction. Suicide is evidence of this, and highlights
an important truth: that many of us would rather die than live in misery—that happiness is even more important than survival, and misery is worse
than death.
Misery is the feeling of stagnation or regression (destruction). Now,
think about happiness—not just fun or pleasure, but the most real and powerful
kind of happiness. What does it feel like? It's a deep, lasting, positive,
productive, peaceful, trusting, clear-thinking, energizing motivation that
draws our minds outward, forward, and upward—to other people, to the future,
and to greater awareness. It makes us focused and present and hopeful.
It's a state of self-perpetuating, powerful, resilient growth that unites,
organizes, and strengthens. Does that sound familiar? It should,
because it mirrors life's own definition: organized, self-directed, energetic growth. Happiness is the point of
life because, very literally,happiness is life, in its ideal state. Happiness is the feeling of life (growth or progress).
Consciousness makes us aware
that we're alive, as well as
how alive we are. We're hungry when we're not fully fed. We're thirsty when
not fully hydrated. And we're unhappy when we're not fully alive. Again,
life is not just on or off—it's a gradient. We don't crave "barely alive."
We crave real, complete happiness.
If you ask someone why they did something, then why they did
that, and follow the chain of logic long enough, your [kind of childish] interrogation
will always end up in the same place. Conscious or not, effective or not,
it will always have been an attempt at happiness. Happiness is the reason
we want to preserve life, or do
anything.
Even though we all want it, we don't automatically know what it
is, or what it feels like (never having been satisfied doesn't stop you
from feeling hungry). We can get off track, and settle for less than we
should. Some of that misunderstanding comes from how we use the word itself:
"Happy Birthday!"
"Happy New Year!"
"A happy medium"
"Put on a happy face"
"Happy hour"
"Happy-go-lucky"
"The happiest place on earth"
The result of over- or mis-using a word is that it muddies the concept.
Perhaps we say the word "happy" so much because we want it to seem more
attainable or easier to give, but there's an actual risk: that we think
it's nothing more than the shallow, temporary thing implied by those phrases—something
we can buy, visit, give, or that will happen to us.
In the case of happiness, ignorance
isn't bliss. It's better to be a little unhappy but know there's more than to
settle for shallow happiness because we don't know or believe there's anything
better. True happiness—though less common than it should be—is real, deeply
satisfying, and generally within reach.
Because happiness is a state of
being, you can't be made fully happy (or unhappy) by someone else. Excited,
maybe. Frustrated, uncomfortable, or sad? Definitely. But happiness is
most affected by our own choices—by what we choose to do and be.
How a person treats others is the simplest way to know how happy
they are. Those who are happy wish the same for others, and those who are miserable
usually wish misery on others. Ignore what people
have and look at how they
behave. Those who are unkind are also unhappy.
Like flight, happiness is an elevated state available to anyone who follows
the laws associated with it, possible even with life's many downward and
turbulent forces. The natural laws of happiness are almost entirely based
on two principles: Truth and Virtue.
–
Truth
Reality is everything as it was, is, and will be. Truth is an accurate
description of reality, which means it's unchangeable and absolute. Knowledge
is awareness of truth. Perception, opinions, thoughts and ideas, imagination,
and beliefs are not necessarily truth, and they don't change truth—they
simply align with it, or not.
Life depends on truth. To survive and thrive we have to be aware of ourselves
and our surroundings, what affects us, and the impact of our actions. Without
truth, we're flying blind. Truth lets us improve and predict our outcomes.
It informs every decision we make.
What we know is the result of what we've been taught and have experienced.
Every new experience is a kind of awakening to some truth, and every bit
of knowledge makes us more capable of growth. At birth we know little,
but we learn quickly. That learning eventually slows, thanks to a brain
increasingly less open to new information, the limitations of our senses,
a growing set of assumptions and opinions, over-confidence and a tendency
toward pride, and fewer
new experiences.
With the ability to communicate comes one of the crown jewels of intelligence:
teaching. It's one of life's most amazing efficiencies—that one person
can share with many others (at the same time) the lessons learned from
individual experience. We don't have to experience what they did to learn
what they learned, so we can quickly absorb many lifetimes' worth of distilled
truth through nurture, conversation, education, churches, books, and other
media. However, that's all based on an assumption of accuracy and trustworthiness
(truth and virtue). Inevitably, some of that information will prove to
be false, and some of the sources unreliable.
Sight and Perception
Once we've been mislead or misinformed we learn that information is not
always truth. We start to doubt—to believe only what we experience, or
understand—and that costs us most of the benefit of human intelligence,
communication, and society. Some trust only what they can see for themselves,
and while that could seem reasonable—maybe even necessary in a sea of misinformation—it's
far less wise than it might sound. Sight is certainly
useful, but also severely limited. Consider:
Most of reality isn't visible.
The vast majority of what affects our daily life—that makes up the universe—isn't
visible to us. Between dark matter, anti-matter, transparent matter (like
the air around us), quantum states, dimensions, forces (like gravity, magnetism,
and atomic bonds), atomic components too small to be observable, and the
increasingly massive scale of the universe, we won't see in our lifetime
more than a tiny fraction of a percent of what actually exists.
Eyes (and brains) aren't perfect.
Sight relies on eyes, and eyes rely on notoriously defective structures*
and relatively few photons that happen to wobble directly into our tiny
pupils.
Understanding what we see is limited both by our imperfect eyes and our mental capacity
to process the information they provide. The result being that even what
we
do see isn't complete, properly understood, or fully reliable.
*
About 10% of us are color blind and a similar percentage are visually
impaired, about 70% of us end up needing glasses, and 100% of us can't
see outside a narrow slice of the electromagnetic spectrum. Other animals
can do far better.
Sight doesn't guarantee understanding, and
not seeing doesn't guarantee ignorance (or non-existence). Truth is truth,
whether or not we can see it. Maximizing our understanding of truth means
using more than just sight.
Another bad habit of human nature is to accept only the bits of truth
that suit us—the parts we understand, or with which we agree. We seem to
prefer comfort and self-assurance over truth. Even stranger than picking
and choosing truths to accept, some of us believe that
whatever we think, feel, or perceive
is truth. "Our" truth. Personal experience is certainly
part of truth, but the distinction between truth and perception is significant—especially
considering how inaccurate perception can be. For example:
Loss of a sense
- Being blind doesn't cause anything to stop existing, but it limits our
ability to perceive reality—as does being deaf, paralyzed, or anosmic.
Just because you don't experience it doesn't mean it's not there.
Dreams/delirium -
Physical consciousness has its limits and flaws, and
it's possible to perceive and react to something that's not there at all.
So, what you do experience doesn't always mean it
is there.
Mishearing or Misunderstanding -
We have imperfect senses and processing, and therefore flawed perception.
What we think we saw or heard may not be what was actually done or said,
or we could be misinterpreting, or missing context.
Memory
- Brains are pack rats. They do a magnificent job of
storing everything—but struggle to find it. Memories also pass through the filter
of our emotions on their way in
and out, and what was stored in the first place is subject to our senses and
brain. Memory is changeable. As a result, it can be unreliable.
Mental Illness -
Failures in the brain and body can lead to irrational thoughts and destructive
acts. Brain damage, trauma, depression, anxiety, paranoia, phobias, and
poor mental or emotional health dramatically alter perception, and in mostly
problematic ways.
Chemicals -
The substances produced by or added to our body distort and/or slow our
perception. Whether it's hormones, alcohol, drugs, etc., the disconnect
from reality can be significant, and frequently dangerous.
Pride, Prejudice, Opinions, Anger, and Pain -
These warp reality as much as mental illness, and have a tendency to cause
us to believe what we wish to believe, and very commonly, what we fear.
These emotional distortions can completely close our mind to new, real,
or critical information.
The unreliable nature of perception is what makes it so necessary for
us to find and act on
absolute truth. It's helpful and constructive to try to understand the experiences
and perspectives of those around us, but the only way for everyone to be
on the same page is to unite around a shared understanding of actual truth.
Encouraging everyone to have their "own truth" creates a society incapable
of unity, harmony, or progress. Having reality in common is a key to individual
and collective happiness.
When information (or perception) falls in line with reality, it's "right,"
and when it doesn't, it is "wrong." Truth encompasses all that's right.
Knowing truth makes us aware of risks and dangers, opportunities and solutions,
resources, causes and effects. Truth protects, moderates, directs, prepares,
and frees us from an endless list of problems.
Misinformation and disinformation, misunderstandings, half-truths and
lies have destroyed health, careers, marriages and families, communities,
and the peace of nations. Lies are used to manipulate, to justify neglect
and abuse, and to initiate and perpetuate conflict. Disconnects from reality
come at the cost of our peace and happiness. Truth matters.
It also has a tendency to reveal itself over time. "Truth will out," as
they say. Like water—you can bury it as deep as you like, but it will eventually
seep out, more clear than before.
There's a reason we try to bury or ignore it. Some truth is unpleasant.
It can be sad, unflattering, complicated, disgusting, overwhelming, and
terrifying. Trusting in the value of truth helps us face it head on (rather
than turning away, and being overturned by it).
Truth is more than knowing things. Facts matter, but truth is
all of reality, so having truth means being
fully connected to reality. Memory and the study of history connect us to the reality of
the past. Focus, awareness, being observant, having clarity of thought,
feeling, and perception, learning and listening, and keeping an open mind
connect us to the reality of the present. Perspective and faith help connect
us to the reality of what will be (more on that later). That's a much deeper
and more valuable type of truth than a catalog of factoids.
Truth is a power. So, like every other power, asset, skill, or tool, it's
only constructive when used appropriately. It's not enough to be right
(or "smart"). Truth doesn't make you good. If you know better, you're obligated
to behave better. That's where virtue comes in.
Virtue
Life is growth, and the point of life is happiness, so something is objectively
"good" if it's a net benefit to growth and happiness. Virtue is every good
pattern of thought and behavior. It's a long list: love (which actually
encompasses most virtues), humility, generosity, gratitude, selflessness,
sacrifice, thoughtfulness, patience, focus, work ethic, etc. But the list
being long doesn't mean we get to pick and choose (like Epicureans and
Stoics, Liberals and Conservatives, etc.), because
vice will exist wherever virtue doesn't, like darkness and light. And every vice is, by definition, net destructive.
It's easier to destroy, fall, relax, delay, or ignore than to build, climb,
work, plan, or study. Progress requires energy. Nature tends to favor efficiency
(except when it comes to fight, flight, play, or reproduction)—but nature is content with survival. Happiness (the apex of intelligent life) requires effort that goes beyond
reaction or instinct.
The term "vice" is often used as a synonym of addiction. A better and
broader definition is that it's simply the opposite of virtue—behavior
with a net effect of destruction and misery (including, but not limited to addiction). Vice is usually the result of doing whatever is easiest.
Virtue demands conscious, sustained effort, and is unnatural only in the
sense that it's not easy (at first), so it doesn't tend to be our default
behavior, but the pursuit of happiness
is natural. Living together in families, groups, and societies
is natural. And virtue (tied to truth) is what makes living together possible
and enjoyable. Vice makes it difficult and unsustainable. Effort makes
all the difference.
Not all vice is moral failure. It's always
destructive, but not always
willful. Conscious effort is still the key, but there's a difference between
vice we choose, and the vice we just haven't finished addressing.
A world without virtue is a place full of division, fear, anger, impatience,
intolerance, selfishness, willful ignorance, and arrogance, where might
makes right, manipulation (mostly violence) is our only attempt at diplomacy,
self-gratification is the only rule, and humanity exists in a state of
absurdly self-destructive anarchy no less intelligent creature could replicate—an
ultimate demonstration of humanity's paradoxical intelligence and foolishness.
Why is vice so common? Because it's easy to do, and easy to sell. Telling
people to give in to selfishness, short-sightedness, self-superiority,
fear, or anger is like telling children they should only eat dessert. It's
appealing because it requires no effort, and satisfies our most base cravings.
It's often fun, flattering, what we want to hear, or are willing to believe.
But the outcome of vice is not happiness. It's not progress. Eventually,
it leads to a complete disconnect from reality. And when public figures,
governments, organizations, sources of information, or companies appeal
to our base instincts rather than motivating us to higher levels of truth
and virtue, the result—regardless of whatever utopia they promise—is damage
to society and individuals. It's a trade of
everyone's peace and happiness for some person's short-term personal gain. If you
don't want the destruction vice brings, don't buy into it.
Nobody has a monopoly on vice. The pull of gravity affects us all more
or less equally, and vice, being natural, does the same. No group—rich
or poor, educated or ignorant, religious or otherwise, one color or another—is
naturally more affected than any other. Pride, laziness, closed-mindedness,
extremism, selfishness…they afflict us all. Vice is a
human problem, so every one of us has to individually choose to resist it.
Vice is often portrayed in art or ads as funny, harmless, or an endearing
part of someone's personality. That may be true—temporarily. When you're
close to it, the charm quickly fades. What we willfully ignore in accepting
or defending vice is the fact that we (humanity and all of nature) are
thoroughly connected. We depend on each other, and our actions affect everyone
and everything around us—when virtuous, for the better, and when not, for
the worse. Recognize vice for what it is: net destructive behavior. Put
in the effort necessary to replace it with virtue, no matter how unusual,
unnatural, or difficult that may feel. Misery is easy, and popular, but
happiness is worth the effort.
The virtue any person has is the result of effort. Yes, virtues require
more energy, but that is the nature of
all great things, including life itself. Consistently giving into our cravings
and impulses results in vice and base, animal-like behavior focused only
on individual survival. Controlling (not neutralizing) ourselves leads
to virtue, and an elevated, increasingly happy state of being that benefits
everyone.
Truth and Virtue
Virtue leads to truth. You may have noticed that moderation, humility,
open-mindedness, thoughtfulness, patience, love, and wisdom motivate us
to seek truth,
and protect us against the lies and misinformation that stem from reality-distorting
bias, extremism, fear, greed, pride, or anger. Each virtue also helps ensure
the constructive application of truth. Look at truth
without virtue:
Truth without justice is hypocrisy
Truth without mercy is criticism
Truth without love is rudeness
Truth without humility is arrogance
Truth without wisdom is tactlessness
Truth without restraint is gossip
Truth without loyalty is betrayal
Truth is truth, but that doesn't justify its misuse. Unkindness isn't
wrong because of inaccuracy. How many times have you heard someone say,
"Look, I'm not going to lie to you…," followed by something nobody should
ever say? It would be a miserable place if everyone were perfectly truthful,
but also critical, hypocritical, unkind, arrogant, tactless, gossiping
traitors who demand to be "right." While truth generally
contributes to happiness, using and distributing it carelessly
doesn't. It's so easily manipulated to manipulate. Truth is a power, so whether
or not it's constructive depends on how it's used. It should be
part of our foundation, but it's not enough to ensure happiness on its own.
Truth needs to be married to virtue.
The truth-virtue relationship goes both ways. Virtue without truth is
also problematic. A few examples:
Myths
- Ideas like Santa Clause or the Easter Bunny might promote generosity
and thoughtfulness, but at a cost (for example, forgetting the actual significance
of events and traditions, children not realizing the sacrifices of their
loved ones, parents being pressured to spend beyond their means, excessive
focus on things rather than relationships, the manipulation of children,
and the breach of trust when they discover the actual truth).
Mantras
- Telling ourselves something is true before it actually is puts the cart
before the horse. Even if those ideas are positive or kind or hopeful,
they are still a willful disconnect from reality—an attempt to wish something
into existence that we could much more effectively
work into existence. Positivity is good, but can easily become denial, which
is bad.
Fad diets
- Yes, they require self-denial and self-control, but often ignore our
individual needs and differences, and can deprive us of critical nutrition
when not based on truth. Virtuous, yes, but potentially destructive. Someone
recommending it doesn't make it good.
Cults and extremist groups
- Sacrifice, obedience, and dedication are all present—right along with
destructive subjugation, acts of violence, loss of self-respect, autonomy,
and even life. Some of history's most horrific events are the result of
a person manipulating others with lies, to take advantage of the motivation,
support, unity, and productivity that virtue generates.
Bad investments
- Long-term thinking, sacrifice, and hope can still lead to a net loss
if the expectation was not based on reality. All investment will come with
risk as long as the future is unknown, but it still points to the value
of truth and the inadequacy of virtue alone.
Crusades and witch hunts
- Whether we're talking about the medieval, religious type, or modern-day
philosophical fervor, these have been destructive as a result of being
based on falsehoods. We ought to defend what is right and good, but going
on the offensive requires a rare degree of justification only provided
by necessity and clear understanding of absolute truth—not just belief.
A world with virtue but no truth is a place where our time and efforts
are wasted on misguided goals, our emotional energy is exhausted by incorrect
perceptions, our hope and belief end in disappointment, and we suffer constant
[though unintentional] damage to our bodies, relationships, finances, communities,
and global peace. We are at our best and happiest when we apply our virtue
to what is true and real.
Knowledge leads to understanding, empathy, humility, love, and open-mindedness.
It strengthens virtue. Virtue encourages us to listen, learn, consider,
serve, and improve ourselves—all of which increase knowledge. Individual
virtues similarly depend on each other.
Everything anyone does is for an imagined benefit. Even the most horrible
acts were done with some positive outcome in mind. The difference is that
destructive acts involve:
Being disconnected from reality (expecting something that is unlikely
or impossible, because of a lack of truth), or
Only looking at
personal benefit and not
net benefit (which implies a lack of virtue)
Right and wrong, good and bad, are
not arbitrary constructs of human imagination, culture, morality, or religion.
They can be contextual and nuanced, but they're still absolute measurements
of reality, and laws of happiness as unchangeable and universal as gravity.
The two most fundamental requirements for human happiness and growth are
truth and virtue.
Virtues and Assets
Life requires resources. Wellness requires resources. It's natural to
hoard assets because of the potential benefit to our survival, but that
basic instinct is problematic for two reasons:
1) In spite of what our body may want (survival), the conscious, intelligent
part of us would actually rather die than live a long, miserable life.
The point of life isn't life. The point of life is happiness, and assets
have little effect on that beyond the threshold needed for survival and
wellness.
2) Assets are limited, but there's no limit to our craving for them. Without
conscious intervention we'll continue to collect them, past the point where
our greed starts to prevent the survival and well-being of others.
Assets benefit survival and virtues benefit happiness. Knowledge—being
a combination of asset and virtue—benefits both. Wellness is an important
part of happiness, and it requires assets, but not many.
Unlike most assets, virtues can't be inherited, given, or taken away.
They are only possessed by someone as a result of individual will (the
core of identity). This makes virtue the only accurate measure of someone's
"goodness" or value.
Regardless of our effort to earn wealth, health, power, or beauty, misfortune
and failure can follow. Many assets can be found or taken away in one moment.
Assets depend significantly on circumstance. But when a person works to
develop humility, generosity, open-mindedness, love, or any other virtue,
even the greatest catastrophes (or "successes") won't deprive that person
of the virtues they acquired—and will in most cases
accelerate their self-improvement.
Like virtues, assets are self-feeding. Wealth leads to education, education
to skill, skill to more wealth and influence, and all add to greater health
and opportunity for more assets. Also like virtues, the absence or decrease
of some assets will usually decrease the other assets as well. Reduced
wealth leads to reduced health and influence, time, and energy. This causes
self-reinforcing cycles of inequality—wealth or poverty—often in spite
of choice.
Just as virtues perfect other virtues (and our use of truth) virtues also
perfect our use of assets. Wherever an asset exists, its corresponding
virtue(s) must be developed or the asset will have a corrosive effect.
Combining external assets with internal virtues creates growth.
A few examples:
Wealth + Generosity
Opportunity + Work Ethic
Intelligence + Wisdom
Strength + Determination
Beauty + Kindness
Skill + Service
Education + Open-Mindedness
Fame + Selflessness
Energy + Focus
Influence + Self-Control
When left ungoverned, assets tend to destroy (like all types of power),
but when properly controlled they are wonderfully useful. The law of entropy
tells us active effort is required to avoid a state of chaos and uselessness.
The more internal control a person achieves, the more external control
they will also have. And when asset and virtue are combined, happiness
is preserved, and capacity for doing good increases.
Gratitude is the willful act of acknowledging the assets we have been
given by others, and consciously choosing to share our thanks and pay that
debt forward—even when some other needs go unmet, or wants remain unfulfilled.
This creates happiness for both giver and receiver, and makes us resistant
to disappointment and discontent. That positive effect grows and spreads.
In contrast, entitlement and ingratitude cause us to be unhappy and unsatisfied,
regardless of how much we have or how much others help us, and discourages
generosity in both ourselves and those who would otherwise have tried to
help us. It diminishes happiness and growth. Gratitude is only one example,
but every virtue can and should be applied to our assets (and every area
of life).
Virtue is so important to individual and collective well-being that it
should be valued above any asset the world has to offer. No economy can
ever be healthy enough to survive widespread vice. Societies usually fall
from the inside out. Virtue is the only guarantee of long-term prosperity.
Truth, virtue, and assets do—and must—go together, producing only when
combined the kind of prosperity and happiness every society seeks.
Knowledge
Knowledge bridges the gap between asset and virtue. It's obtained by any
who seek it, and is constructive when balanced and moderated. It's like
an asset in that having less doesn't make a person less good—it's simply
an awareness that increases our
potential for good or bad. But it does have a stronger tendency than most other
assets to encourage virtue, and is like a virtue in that it isn't easily
taken away, or conferred on those who don't want or seek it.
Skill (specific knowledge + process) is also between asset and virtue.
It's a capacity developed through effort, and is based on truth, but is
more narrow in application than virtue, and is often but not
inherently constructive. Like knowledge, it increases potential for good
or bad. This includes abilities like communication, leadership, organization,
and more—which are possessed in spades by the most constructive
and destructive individuals in history.
Knowledge and skill will accelerate our efforts, whether or not we want
what is good. So, wanting what is good is the higher priority.
Identifying Truth
Truffles—one of the most prized foods on the planet—can sell for hundreds
of thousands of dollars per pound, and grow underground, which makes them
very difficult to find. Locating them requires an understanding of where
and when to look, as well as a truffle-hunting companion capable of rooting
them out. Truth is similar. It's deeply valuable, though sometimes hidden,
and finding it requires that we know where to look, and have the ability
to identify it. For a world in which truth is increasingly elusive, here's
a simple litmus test:
Is the source moderate and unbiased?
Is the source reliable and trustworthy?
Is the source corroborated by other sources?
Is the source (and their affiliates) unlikely to benefit from you believing
the information?
Does it feel true?
Does it seem unchangeable, unflattering, or challenging?
Is it consistent with what you already know to be true?
If it can be proven, has it been proven?
If not, is there adequate evidence to support the idea?
Is it simple?
Is it calm and rational?
If it's emotional, does it still hold up to logic?
If based on logic, does the logic hold up if followed to its end?
Is it based on a stable premise or accurate assumptions?
Does it generally avoid assumptions or opinions?
Has it stood the test of time?
Does it seem likely to stand the test of time?
Is it constructive?
Does it encourage virtue—to do good or be wise, calm, loving, open-minded,
and focused on the well-being of others?
Does it acknowledge that all people are fundamentally equal?
Does it encourage, accept, and withstand verification?
If the answer is "yes" to those questions, the information is almost certainly
true. If the answer to
any of those questions is "no," that should throw up a red flag, and you'd
need additional verification or proof.
It's easy to believe what we
want to believe. It's easier to believe
who we want to believe. And, unfortunately, the easiest of all is believing
what we
fear. But truth is rarely just want we want, always from people we like, or
actually as bad as we think.
Truth has a nature—a set of consistent characteristics. It's calm, simple,
moderate, consistent, redundant, balanced, supported, connected, centrist,
and inclusive. Truth is valuable. Once you find it, it's worth giving up
all the misunderstandings, false beliefs, theories, traditions, or superstitions
it replaces.
Truth is in the middle
Truth doesn't change. It remains moderate and simple, in spite of the
flood of constantly evolving opinions, perceptions, trends, cultures, movements,
or lies. Truth is simple reality—things as they were, are, and will be.
It's absolute. But, it's in our nature to disagree. Sometimes, we fight
because we know truth is worth defending. We just don't always stop to
consider if we're actually right. And the natural result of conflict is
to push away from one another. Truth remains where it always was: in the
neutral [absolute] middle. As opposing parties polarize away from each
other they move farther and farther away from the center, and from truth.
This makes the arguments of both parties more inaccurate, unstable, extreme,
and justifiably opposed by the other. From either side, truth seems skewed
toward the other, and therefore undesirable, so in addition to fighting
against our opponent we will fight against truth.
The real problem is polarization itself.
So, truth usually ends up in the middle, or more accurately, we tend to
end up on opposite sides of truth. The middle is absolute—not relative
to the two arguments. If one person is right and the other wrong, that
doesn't mean the truth is half wrong. It means the person who is right
is in the middle of the extremes.
Remaining in the center is hard. It takes humility and open-mindedness
and a conscious effort at balance. It requires that we give up our emotional
need to be right or feel smart (or push
too hard against those who deviate from truth). In exchange, we're rewarded
with actual truth and wisdom.
Like climbing a tree, we're most safe and stable near the trunk, and able
to climb to great heights. The farther out on the branches we go, the more
difficult it gets to climb upward, and the more unstable and dangerous
our position becomes.
Unbiased people will agree on truth, because they'll see it for what it
is, and their perspectives, though different, will overlap. Truth often
has many witnesses. When you hear arguments made, or opposing perspectives
presented, it's wise to look to the center, and to any overlap, for truth.
Truth is in the middle.
False Choices
When truth
isn't between two conflicting concepts it can mean
both concepts are true, or contain truth, and are only being
presented as opposing options. Logic or emotion, spending or saving, nutrition or
exercise, work or play, freedom or rules, pleasure or self-denial, conservatism
or liberalism, religion or science… These false choices are destructive
because
both sides are critical to happiness. When compatible truths are presented
as opposing arguments, someone is either confused, or wants conflict. The
result of picking one or the other is that you will lose
half of all that is good, and what remains is not properly moderated. Truth never actually opposes
itself—even when it seems to—but it usually requires balance.
Change
While truth itself remains perfectly consistent, every
thing in the universe changes. There are changes in direction, velocity, position,
energy, shape, and order. The fundamental laws of nature and physics remain
constant, but their effect is an ever-evolving system—life being the most
dynamic and complex of all. Life is change. It's self-directed, self-motivated
growth and regeneration
through and in spite of change. The more intelligent life is, the more it can act rather than being
acted upon, to change itself and its circumstances. Intelligence enables
progress. Happiness requires growth, because it's based on truth and virtue,
neither of which we have in full at the beginning of our life. So, change
is necessary.
Freedom is the condition of being
allowed to act, and to progress. When freedom is removed we lose our ability to self-direct,
to choose change, to discover truth, and to connect with others. This opposes
what defines life and facilitates happiness. Few things are more destructive
than the removal of freedom. Even being made to do
good won't produce happiness, because it neither creates virtue nor encourages
learning. Systems, products, and choices that needlessly reduce our freedoms
(physical, mental, emotional, social, financial, political, religious,
etc.), are objectively wrong. Addictions and dependencies, debts, abuses,
enslavement, manipulation, oppression, tyranny, and persecution of all
kinds stand against everything essential to happiness—against well-being,
autonomy, truth, virtue, and progress. Providing and protecting freedom
will never
guarantee happiness, but it ensures two things: the best conditions for progress,
and individual responsibility for happiness (or misery).
A philosophy that proposes that we're not capable of change, don't need
to change, or would be happier if we stopped trying to change, is not just
incorrect—it halts growth, encourages stagnation and inaction, defends
destruction, and robs individuals of real happiness, leaving in its place
only shallow, false, and temporary self-assurance. It's clear that people
can change for the worse, when they so choose. We can change for the better
as well.
Similarly, the idea that it's not personal change, but growth of assets
(money, health, beauty, power, etc.) that will bring happiness is destructively
misguided, and is supported by neither logic nor history. It produces individuals
who have spent their lives amassing assets
instead of virtues, inevitably at the expense of their own happiness, and to the
detriment of those whose basic needs remain unmet.
We are who we are, and we don't need to be someone else. But, being who
we are doesn't mean remaining
as we are. A seed is a seed, but it shouldn't stay a seed. Your potential
is a part of who you are. Progress helps you become what you can and should
be—the most complete, mature, developed, productive, and happy version
of yourself.
Who and what you are is defined by what you most deeply want and choose.
You can want and choose to change. Growing into the person you really want
to be is the only way to
actually be yourself. When we change in ways that make us better—that increase
knowledge and virtue, and that bring our actions in line with what we know
to be true, and feel to be true (conscience)—happiness grows. There's no
happiness without change, and personal progress, though hard, is absolutely
possible.
Many of us don't choose to change simply because we don't think others
will believe we have. We think they'll only see us as we
were. We're stuck in how we perceive ourselves, or think others do. Living
up to expectations is one thing. Living
down to expectations is another, and is wrong. It won't bring happiness.
People can become better or worse, but that isn't predetermined
or permanent. Our pursuit of truth and virtue is how we choose what our net
benefit will be. Whatever it was in the past, we can change, accept additional
truth, embrace more virtue, and become more good (or, conversely, accept
lies and resist truth, give in to vice, and become more bad). Reputation
is an asset that can be damaged by past behavior—but, being an asset, it
was never a good metric for character in the first place. Forget what people
think. Change, and embrace what is true and good. Happiness outlasts reputation.
Some things make change easier: goals, plans, routines, memory, imagination,
inspiration, hope, companionship—and most of all, desire. Change starts
with wanting to be happy, then increasing truth by:
Acknowledging our ignorance
Wanting more truth
Seeking it
Verifying it
Accepting it
Changing anything about our life in conflict with it, then
Promoting and protecting it
Then, growing in virtue by:
Recognizing our vices
Wanting improvement
Replacing vice with virtue
Sticking to it, then
Encouraging others do the same
As we grow in truth, virtue will also grow, and vice versa.
To summarize: truth is the simple, reasonable, unbiased, single, absolute
reality in which we all live (independent of our perceptions), and what
defines "right," a power to be managed carefully, and the moderate and
stable foundation of virtue.
Virtue is the definition of "good," the full suite of constructive thoughts
and behaviors, the only fair and accurate measurement of individual worth,
and a self-reinforcing set of characteristics that, when paired with truth,
produce real happiness.
The laws of happiness are truth and virtue. The key to parenting is truth
and virtue. The key to leadership, a productive career, relationships,
health, service, teaching, learning, governance, business, finances, science,
religion…the key to
everything is truth and virtue, because the
point of everything is happiness, and the fundamental laws of constructive growth
and happiness
are truth and virtue.
–
Truth is
understanding. Virtue is
being. What remains is
doing. How do we achieve good outcomes more consistently, and what's the process
for applying our hard-earned knowledge and character? That framework is
Wisdom.
Chapter 2
Wisdom
In literature, wisdom is usually a quasi-magical power, possessed for
plot-enhancing reasons by old and mysterious characters who guide our protagonist
to success. In real life, wisdom
does guide us to success, but is less rare, and more attainable. It's more
language than wizardry. Like language, it can be learned by anyone who
practices it. It's common with age, because it's usually a product of experience,
but, like other virtues, it's present in—and only in—those who seek or
accept it. Many of us don't, because it can seem difficult, restraining,
or old-fashioned. The more foolish we are, the more foolish wisdom sounds.
Wisdom is the power to know
what to do (or
not do),
when to do it, and
why. In other words, it's the ability to consistently make good decisions.
Anyone who wants wisdom can develop it. It's a process of thought and action
based on:
Prioritization
Perspective
Patterns
Preparation
Principles
Purpose
Prioritization
We have limited resources. There are infinite ways to spend those resources,
and only a handful of things we will have time to do, so those should be
the ones with the greatest impact on growth and happiness. Prioritization
means figuring out what those are, and ordering them properly.
Decisions are trades. We trade our time, energy, money, and other resources
for some perceived benefit. In some cases, we trade our short-term benefit
for a longer-term benefit (an investment or sacrifice). Or, we trade our
long-term benefit for a short-term benefit (indulgence or foolishness).
First, growth requires effort. Second, every decision has long-term consequences.
Those two facts mean that constructive decisions will almost always require
a short-term sacrifice, and result in long-term increase in happiness.
That's the pattern of exercise, nutrition, education, relationships, construction,
developing any skill—essentially every good thing. On the other hand, destructive
decisions follow another pattern: giving in, taking the easy road, and
accepting small, immediate payoffs with long-term detriments (e.g. laziness,
procrastination, manipulation, criticism, conflict, gluttony, drugs). It's
wise to prioritize
net gain over immediate gain.
Prioritizing our needs and wants (in that order) helps make sure we trade
up, not down. A need is anything required to avoid destruction and misery.
Wants are optional and being deprived of them
optionally affects our well-being and happiness. It's trading up when we redirect
our limited energy from wants to needs (or from wants to more meaningful
wants). Always trade up.
We typically know when an option is bad. All that requires is self-control.
It's harder to prioritize when we have to choose between two good options
(or two bad ones). There's a time for efficiency, and a time for effectiveness.
There are times to be rigid, and times to be flexible. Focusing on net
effect and trading up helps us prioritize and see the right time for any
option.
Priorities need to be conscious and consistent. We essentially have no
priorities if they change with every decision and circumstance.
Perspective
Thoughts and decisions are products of the past. What has already happened
explains where we are now and the choices available to us. Looking back
at the past enables us see where the ripples of similar actions have gone. Where we want to be in the future determines
whether we should keep doing what we're doing, or change. In other words,
we should think in context, with both past and future in mind, guided by
our goals. This allows us to change our direction as needed, and better
control our outcomes. How well can you build something if you don't remember
what you've already completed or what you meant for it to be? Focusing
on where you are right now is good and important—but useless without the
perspective of past and future.
A key to making good decisions is considering their net effect in the
broadest sense. Every decision has its pros and cons. The direct and indirect,
close and distant, immediate and delayed, obvious and subtle, quantifiable
and intangible results of any thing are its net effect. Those ripples—which
may grow
or diminish with time—are impossible for us to calculate fully, but even
a good old college try helps you see past the immediate effects of an action
and sense if that action had a net effect of happiness and growth. The
broader our perspective, the more accurate our perception of net effect
will be.
Machiavelli is famous for his hypothesis that "the end justifies the means."
While that is clearly prone to misuse, it does hold true
if the "end" includes
all the effects of the means throughout all of time,
and the sum is a net effect of growth and happiness. The end isn't just what
happens to
us —it's the effect on
everyone affected by our decisions. Selfishness is wrong because it only considers
the effect on one's self, even if enormous damage is done to others. It
ignores
net effect. Wisdom keeps the far-reaching effects of action in mind.
The Iroquois people of North America had a guiding principle for their
decisions: that they must be sustainable for seven generations. That kind
of thinking encourages us to intentionally design highly constructive,
long-term solutions. Think of what we
wouldn't do (or make, sell, buy, or eat) if guided by the same principle. Sustainability
is a critical facet of wisdom that considers the future effects of our
decisions.
The reality that choice changes the direction of the future gives you
great power—if you know where you want to go and have the self-control
to make yourself choose what is best. Those who choose only what they want
in the moment fail to remember the course-changing nature of decisions,
and the fact that "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure." Every
bad decision leaves you with fewer good options. It takes far less energy
overall to make small, frequent adjustments than to make major course corrections.
A boat can't do much to prevent the wind or waves from pushing it around,
but it
can control the direction in which it's pointed. The more frequently it corrects
its course the sooner it will get to its destination. Choice is how we
control our direction.
The first three dimensions of reality (width, height, and depth) allow
for scale and position, shape, and mass. But time, the fourth dimension,
is what permits change, and therefore motion, energy, light, heat, growth,
life, consciousness, and action. Like all dimensions there is no discernible
end to time. The span of our life from birth to death is relatively
short. Keeping an eternal perspective while carefully managing the limited
time we have is constructive and wise. There are good, better, and best
times for most actions. If there is no time in which an action will be
net constructive, it's inherently wrong.
Another key to perspective is recognizing how little we know. Given the
vastness of the universe, the portion of our brain in full use,
the short duration of our life, and the limits of our own experience, we
should be both humble and hopeful—keeping ourselves open to the nearly
infinite volume of knowledge we have yet to acquire. This will ensure our
perspective and knowledge continue to grow.
Seeing the world through only our own perspective is like seeing through
only one eye. The depth and clarity of what we perceive can be enhanced
by gathering perspective from others. In doing so we tap into one of the
most significant treasures of society:
collective wisdom.
Patterns
The laws of nature are reliable. Newton's observations about motion have
remained accurate. The sun consistently keeps planets in their orbit, and
we can count on the laws of energy, motion, and thermodynamics. Recognizing
patterns in nature allows us to make constructive decisions: how to care
for our bodies, homes, communities, and world, where and how to build,
when and how to grow food, and how best to prepare for inevitable cycles
of growth and destruction. Patterns in nature are the basis of technology,
medicine, and science (not to mention music and art).
Many of these patterns have value as metaphors for life and happiness.
The fundamental principles are similar. Winter is replaced by spring, and
suffering is usually temporary and followed by growth. Change brings progress
as often as it brings challenges. We might be tired of hearing that "the
early bird gets the worm," but wise people learn principles from patterns in the world
around them. Nature has managed to achieve and sustain beauty, complexity,
efficiency, growth, variety, harmony, and balance for billions of years.
Those are some of our most important goals, so we should try to recognize
nature's principles and patterns.
Laws of happiness are natural, and therefore as consistent as the rest
of nature, and patterns of human behavior are similarly predictable. The
causes and effects of pride, conflict, or corruption in people thousands
of years ago is no different from what we see now. The benefits of unity,
order, balance, virtue, or mercy are also unchanged by time. Certain behaviors
have certain outcomes. This tendency of truth to follow patterns and provide
predictable outcomes gives us a valuable guide for thought and decisions.
We can more easily work constructively with others when our approach and
expectations are based on reliable patterns. What has worked in the past
is the thing most likely to work in the future. Discovery is important,
but there is risk in relying too much on ideas not yet proven by time (and
in discarding truths that
have been proven by time).
It's also helpful to be aware of patterns of behavior, both in others
and in ourselves. Understanding those patterns helps us predict and therefore
change outcomes. This is, in a nutshell, the entire concept behind parenting,
psychology, education, diplomacy, law enforcement and security, addiction
treatment, and on, and on. The ordered nature of life means that behavior
is seldom as random as it seems (people are always rational—within the
context of what they know and feel, and the limits of how clearly they
can think). Understanding behavior is possible and extremely constructive.
Patterns reveal principles, powers, and probabilities. It's the recurring
theme of cause and effect that enables us to see what's beneficial and
what isn't, what's wise and what isn't, the forces at play, and the likely
result of any choice. These pattern-based revelations enable us to base
our expectations on what's reliable, real, and likely, which then protects
us against disappointment, confusion, anger, and disaster.
Patterns of behavior aren't necessarily good. It's been said that a fool
is someone who keeps doing the same thing, expecting a different result.
A wise person, then, would learn from the patterns of the past, employ
thoughts and actions that have a tendency to lead to the desired outcome,
then change course as often as needed.
Patterns are the rhythm of life. It's wise to observe the recurring themes
and stay in harmony with them.
Preparation
Priorities, perspective, and patterns all point toward the value of preparing
for the future. When we know what is most important, what has happened
in the past and where things are headed, what the short- and long-term
effects of action (or inaction) would be, what powers are at play, and
what to expect based on the continuity of the laws of physics and human
nature, our decisions can do far more to ensure a good result. The alternative
is to simply react to the present, which gives us dramatically reduced
control over our future.
Non-human animals understand this concept perfectly. They have a keen
ability to observe the subtle cues of nature, recognize what is coming,
and immediately begin preparing. This is true for common, cyclical challenges
(like the coming of winter), and even more random events (storms or tsunamis).
Human animals would also be wise to observe as carefully, respond as immediately,
and work to ensure a good outcome as wisely by preparing for change and
the needs it will create.
Preparation is about the future, and to us the future is largely unknown.
As a result, any preparation involves some degree of risk. We are putting
out energy and resources for a benefit we can't fully predict, which
could potentially turn out to have been a waste. Preparing is risky. But
not preparing is unwise, and guarantees worse outcomes. Risk is simply a part
of life. It's a necessary component of health, relationships, careers,
financial well-being, farming, education—essentially everything we do.
Finding the appropriate degree of risk is mostly a matter of preparing
for the future with perspective, and with the guidance of historical patterns.
Long-term focus is critical, but it's wise to have both a short- and long-term
strategy. This allows us to be prepared not just for the major, infrequent
events, but for the constant day-to-day needs. We save money and educate
ourselves for the possibility of needing a new job some day, but we still
prepare for work or school on a daily basis. We watch the map to make sure
we're heading toward our destination,
and carefully watch the road so we don't crash. Preparation is the wisdom
to do what can reasonably be done now to control the future—to benefit
from opportunity
and survive calamity, even when they are infrequent or unlikely. That is best
achieved through small but constant investment of resources. Small changes
now will have large impacts later.
Principles
Just because you
can, doesn't mean you
should. Determining what
should be done is a matter of applying principle to choice. Virtues are those
principles. Unprincipled decisions are prone to failure. Pride, for instance,
leads to anger, closed-mindedness, halted progress, unfounded self-assurance,
and self-centeredness—all of which lead to foolish decisions that are careless,
uninformed, rushed, over-confident, unconsidered, selfish, and ultimately
destructive. On the other hand, humility leads to calm thought, open-mindedness,
learning, realistic and productive confidence, caution, and selflessness,
which in turn result in progress for the individual
and everyone else.
Patience is another good example. The principle of actively waiting (preserving
sufficient time for good outcomes) is another wise application of virtue.
It guides us to do things when they will have their greatest positive effect,
rather than acting impulsively. Some parts of life cannot be [successfully]
rushed.
Happiness is rarely accidental. Making decisions based on principles of
virtue is the only way to guarantee net gain and progress. Choices that
are in line with your conscience—what you know or sense is right and good—also
guarantee freedom from the misery of guilt, regret, fear, shame, or self-loathing
(not to mention just condemnation). Truth—virtue's complementary principle—should
also be at the center of every decision.
Purpose
Knowing the outcome you want most helps avoid impulsive, short-selling,
irrational decisions. Nobody wants to live in a home or drive in a car
that was constructed thoughtlessly or by accident. Most parts of life are
better when they're the result of desire and design—thoughtful intent and
systematic execution.
Determine your purpose and be motivated by it. Move toward your goals
with every decision, and ignore criticism and distractions that bend you
away. Pleasing critics is both impossible and unnecessary. Long term, the
motive should
always be net increase in happiness. So, short-term goals should be in line with
that overarching purpose, the way the elements of a blueprint should all
contribute to the function and beauty of the final structure, or the ingredients
and methods of a recipe should all enhance the final dish.
When you think about what defines you
as a unique, distinct being—when you've stripped away the parts that were
inherited or taught or caused by circumstance—what is left is only your
personal
desire. Whatever it is you want most deeply. Your
will. We are more than the sum of our body parts, upbringing, past decisions,
or present circumstances. Identity goes beyond body, behavior, assets,
and occupation. Those outer layers can, perhaps should, and often will
change. That change should be driven by what you want most. Discover what
you want most, and you will learn who you are. Being in harmony with your
own purpose and identity is key to happiness.
In our pursuit of what we desire, it's also wise to recognize that as
part of a society, what we want, do, and take influences the communities
in which we live—for good or bad. When we take at the expense of our community,
we cause conditions detrimental to everyone's happiness, including
our own. For that reason, what we want for ourselves should always be
balanced by what we want our community to be like (locally, nationally,
and globally). This is the concept of the Golden Rule: doing ourselves
(first) what we hope everyone will do (eventually)
because of the kind of community it would create. This requires some sacrifice, but is the only way to break the cycles of vice that make societies unhappy.
With a clear, conscious, motivating desire behind every action, foolish
distractions and tempting short-sells are easier to ignore, challenges
are easier to overcome, goals are significantly easier to achieve, and
our life has direction. Purpose is our destination, sail, wind, and rudder.
–
A wise person gathers and internalizes truth, develops and employs virtue,
focuses on the highest priority, prepares for the future, manages expectations,
and acts purposefully for the greatest probability of long-term happiness.
The benefits may come slowly, but "wisdom is justified of her children."
Wisdom is like chess: know your goal, prioritize, prepare, have a short-
and long-term strategy, understand the patterns, trade up (focus on net
gain), and keep moving toward your goal in spite of setbacks.
Wisdom doesn't need to be original. It it's not new, nor the idea of any
single person. It may sound familiar, old-fashioned, simple—even obvious.
Wisdom isn't intelligence, and it doesn't require unusual intelligence
(intelligent people are often foolish, and ignorant people can be wise).
It's defined by the
process of thought and action we choose to follow. It
does require that we pay attention and learn from experience, and it rests,
like anything else important to happiness, on a foundation of virtue and
truth.
Mastering any new language takes time, but wisdom is a language worth
learning. The more people there are who speak it, the more unified, peaceful,
and productive society will be.
–
Knowing, being, and doing what is most constructive is largely an individual
effort, but some principles require humanity's coordinated energy to support
and preserve happiness for everyone. The first of these are Balance, Equality,
and Unity.
Chapter 3
Balance, Equality, and Unity
If everything were the same, life could not exist. The universe only functions
because of different and opposing elements (mass and space, positive and
negative charges, visible and dark matter, light and dark, temperature
or pressure differentials, gravity and momentum, varying atomic structures,
bonds and the energy that breaks them, etc.). These differences made our
planet and the life on it possible, and allow it to continue.
Zoom in a bit, and you'll see that differences in ecosystems support a
wider variety of life, and variety of life provides balance and function.
Gender differences help perpetuate life with greater efficiency, and other
differences allow the current variety of life to coexist in harmony and
symbiosis rather than destructive competition. In nature, differences tend
to be stable, self-perpetuating, sustainable, and productive. They're essential—but
also require balance.
Balance
Imbalance threatens life by causing a circumstance where one opposing
force overcomes, rather than counterbalances, the other,
destroying the differences in that system that would have otherwise contributed to
life. For example, day and night, hot and cold, land and sea—they all provide
conditions necessary to life. Too much of one or the other—or a constant
average—would be far less beneficial. Without balanced differences, everything moves progressively
closer to either sameness or chaos.
Homogeneity (sameness) is the opposite of life. A perfectly uniform universe
filled with nothing but a single, neutral, inert, perfectly distributed
element and no opposing forces would also be devoid of life, form, or any
usefulness. Chaos is also unfriendly to life, which requires structure,
order, balance, and some degree of predictability.
Balance fixes sameness and chaos. It allows for constructive differences
and opposing forces, in a state of organization. It requires active energy,
and is a principle that applies to all things, both literal and figurative.
Imbalance is unsustainable by nature, meaning that it inevitably leads
to destruction—whether we're talking about something as concrete as a building,
or as abstract as our use of time, our philosophies, beliefs, or political
systems.
True principles can seem at odds with each other. That doesn't mean that
one or the other is wrong—it just implies that some differences work together
in harmonious balance, and in many cases are
necessary to each other. For example:
Life and death
Gravity and flight
Justice and mercy
Law and self-governance
Hierarchy and equality
Caring for others and taking care of ourselves
Investment and saving
Generosity and frugality/self-reliance
Teaching and learning
Learning and doing
Leading and following
Patience and action
Confidence and caution
Obedience and self-motivation/self-direction
Logic and emotion
Comfort and discomfort
Flexibility and rigidity
Both sides are good and necessary. Like a thumb opposing the other fingers,
it's a balancing force that allows everything to function properly. Eliminating
one principle or the other would be detrimental.
That said, life does
not need to include what's wrong or bad (net destructive); there's enough
natural opposition from balanced virtues, not to mention the good and natural
parts of life that are difficult, painful, sad, uncertain, or frustrating.
Balance is
not the equal acceptance and protection of both right and wrong—it's the successful
management of contrasting goods that prevents needless destruction and
misery.
Life is complex. It
requires complexity. But, the complexity of nature is purposeful and essential,
while the complexity of our schedules and systems and relationships and
thoughts may not be. Complexity has a tendency to become chaos. Intentional
balance helps us find the point where critical complexity meets sustainable
simplicity.
Balance requires energy. Without effort, imbalance grows. Nature corrects
pent-up imbalance sporadically through major events like earthquakes, volcanoes,
lightning, etc. When imbalance become apparent in our lives or communities,
actively and frequently restoring balance is important, even if it's unpleasant
(change of behavior, habit, routine, way of thinking, diet, attitude, entertainment,
social groups, or sources of information). If balance isn't restored regularly,
we risk larger-scale, sudden, chaotic corrections, in the form of economic
collapse, political divisions, wars and revolutions, starvation, etc. Life
prefers small, frequent adjustments to sustain balance.
Moderation is a balance-focused virtue. It's been treated as if it were
synonymous with apathy, indecision, inaction, or disloyalty, but those
words exist because they mean something different. Moderation is the conscious
act of resisting imbalance and extremism. It's a type of self-control and
requires effort, but pays us back in better outcomes. It's worth noting
that moderation applies even (or specifically) to good things. It's the
wisdom to balance two competing truths, or what's right and good with our
capacity to understand and act, which helps us sustain growth and avoid
burnout. It
isn't a balance between right and wrong, which is simply unprincipled fence-sitting,
or ignorance.
You may not notice [unless you've had vertigo] just how constantly and
actively your body works to avoid falling over. Hundreds of muscles respond
every second to sensory information provided by your inner ear, allowing
you to stand or walk or run. True moderation is similar: a constant recalibration
of every part of our life or society to keep the whole in balance.
Tightrope walking may look easy from the ground, but it's a different
story when you're looking down from a great height on a swaying wire the
width of a finger, with winds, distractions, and the constant risk of death.
Remaining centered, moderate, and in balance is an exceptionally difficult
act of constant micro-adjustments and self-control relatively few of us
achieve—however easy it may look or sound from a distance. It's far easier
to metaphorically fall to the [non-metaphorical] catastrophe of obsession,
extremism, bias, closed-mindedness, or other kinds of imbalance. Moderation
protects truth and virtue.
There's no balance without moderation, and no complete happiness without
balance, which is why it needs to be pursued, practiced, protected, and
promoted—both personally and collectively.
Equality
Equality is a human desire rooted in our innate need for survival (access
to resources) and justice (preservation of social balance and safety).
Inequality—an unequal distribution of power, justice, or resources—ignites
an instinctive, passionate energy that has driven movements like revolution
and war—for both good and bad. Unfortunately, the righteous indignation
that seeks to restore balance, justice, and peace isn't always based on
truth and virtue, but the conflicts of history
are evidence of our natural craving for equality.
Equality, like balance, is not homogeneity. A homogeneous system, as previously
mentioned, is not good. Achieving and preserving equality requires an orderly
system that is not homogeneous, but varied, structured, and balanced. We
wouldn't survive long with a body made of nothing but brains, and a brain
wouldn't survive long if it were made only of nerve cells. We need a bladder
and a brain, a heart and lungs, kidneys and liver, skin, bones, circulatory
system, and a wide variety of cells and tissues and chemicals. Health quickly
disintegrates when even one body part is deprived of what it needs or stops
functioning. On the other hand, life is also endangered when the most crucial
systems aren't prioritized over others—the reason your body prefers to
sacrifice your fingers and ears to frostbite, rather than your brain and
heart and lungs.
It's important to see the distinction between imbalance and hierarchy.
Imbalance is a destructively lopsided distribution that gives preference
to one entity over another
to the detriment of the whole. Hierarchy is a highly constructive and efficient structure capable of
providing alignment and unity to a large group of diverse, individual entities
with different roles,
to the benefit of all. Throughout history, hierarchical systems of government have frequently
(and needlessly) been out of balance—by failure or will—and could wrongly
be perceived as
inherently imbalanced. Having an individual entity at the head of a group only results
in imbalance and inequality when that individual fails to distribute power,
justice, and resources with the well-being of the group as the primary
focus. In other words,
hierarchy requires virtue. It depends on selfless, diligent, thoughtful, trusting, wise, open-minded
action to remain conducive to growth and happiness. Absent virtue, hierarchy
quickly becomes unsustainable imbalance, and eventually destruction. This
is true of any human system, but hierarchy provides the greatest potential
for unity and efficient progress (presumably the reason why nature favors
it for sustaining life). In a hierarchy it's a primary responsibility of
every individual to work to preserve balance and virtue and truth, at every
level. In other words, democracy will protect the whole,
as long as the majority wants what's good. Historically speaking, that is more common than the individual at the
head of a hierarchy consistently wanting what's good.
A house of cards is a good example of structure, balance, equality, and
hierarchy. You may have only a card or two at the top, but the responsibility
and importance of every card is equal as you descend the pyramid. Turn
that pyramid upside down (or even have the same number of cards on each
level), and you have a system that is still structured, balanced, and hierarchical,
but deeply and unsustainably unequal—the weight increasing on each card
as you descend, until it falls with greatest force on the bottom—making
collapse inevitable. Destruction and misery and revolution is the natural
outcome of any system that fails to prioritize and preserve balance, equality,
and structure—a scene that has played out countless times on the human
stage (caste systems, the French Revolution, American Revolution, Red October,
civil rights movements and women's rights, ethnic cleansing, religious
persecution, and on and on). On the other hand, the pyramids of Egypt—designed
and constructed for maximum balance and stability—have lasted, mostly unchanged,
for thousands of years.
A common failing of human nature is to seek sameness rather than equality.
We want the
same roles, the
same responsibilities, the
same information, the
same function, the
same assets, and even the same appearance as others around us. This comes from
an understandable [but misguided] craving for justice, comfort, belonging,
and predictability. But, the most happy and productive state in a system
like family or society is one in which our roles, responsibilities, and
functions are different and complementary, but
valued equally, and distribution of resources is guided by capacity and need.
This arrangement provides place, meaning, identity, and value to every
individual, distributing the burdens of life such that we all bear what
we can handle. It unites everyone in a common purpose, supported by what
they individually need.
Giving every person the same function and responsibility destroys the
value of individuals and most of the benefit of living in groups. Currently,
society
is comprised of people with diverse roles and functions—but, are those individuals
valued equally, and are they all receiving a fair distribution of resources
and power? Compensation for someone's time and labor is one of society's
loudest pronouncements of their perceived worth. When society perpetuates
inequality—whether that be compensation, rights, protections, voice, or
resources—the outcome is predictable misery and failure. Simply expecting
everyone to improve their own situation by giving up their current roles
in favor of a small subset of better compensated ones destroys the valuable
and necessary diversity of society, leaves many important jobs undone,
diminishes the value of the over-saturated roles that remain, and ignores
the reality of circumstance. Expecting the poor to remain poor so the wealthy
can remain wealthy also exposes a complete poverty of truth and virtue.
We are all better off when we contribute in different ways, to the extent
of our capacity, and are valued equally. While others lack what we have
and could share, we bear fault for that inequality and the unhappiness
it causes.
At the heart of inequality is an ugly tumor of truthlessness and vice:
fear, distrust, selfishness, anger, pride, closed-mindedness, criticism,
and lies. The defining symptom of this illness is an insistence that one
individual or group is inherently better (or worse) than another—rich or
poor, educated or not, genders, colors, cultures, or religions. There are
simple and obvious reasons why that shameful falsehood is destructive and
wrong, and why all people should be seen as equal:
The point of societies is
collective success. It's failure if only one part of society "succeeds."
Occupying a different place in the social hierarchy doesn't mean you're better—it simply
means you fulfill a different role, and are responsible for the success
of a larger group of people below you.
The idea that someone being different makes them inferior is a flawed
assumption proven wrong over and over throughout history. Every culture,
color, and gender has produced (and continues to produce) people of exceptional
virtue, knowledge, skill, and contribution to society.
Every person's intrinsic worth is equal. Their goodness is a function
of their individual commitment to truth and virtue—full stop. That is what
determines their net effect on society. Assets like intelligence, skill,
or wealth only accelerate that effect.
The human differences on which we base our judgment tend to be superficial—visible
characteristics that are only skin- or culture-deep.
Our actual differences enrich and strengthen us, and give us value. Throughout
all of nature, variety is better than homogeneity. Everyone being the same
robs individuals of their worth or unique contribution. It's like a meal
with only one ingredient, a painting with only one color, or a song with
only one note. The logical end of every kind of self-supremacy is homogeneity.
If everyone is like you, your worth is destroyed. You have nothing unique
to offer. Variety is good for everyone. We all have a need to be needed.
People are connected, so hurting or helping one group hurts or helps the
rest. Society is like a body—we need and depend on one another, whether
or not we acknowledge it. And ignoring someone's value hurts everyone.
Blaming one group for the ills of society just because they look or believe
or act differently is a predictable tactic of selfish individuals attempting
to manipulate society for power (Hitler, Stalin, KKK, extremists, supremacists,
terrorists, corrupt politicians, etc.), and has resulted in some of the
most horrific atrocities in human history.
Racism, sexism, classism, self-supremacy, prejudice, discrimination, segregation,
intolerance, persecution, political extremism, genocide, self-righteousness,
and victimization are all extraordinarily destructive, and are all the
result of vice (generally pride, fear, and selfishness).
Prejudice is based on fear and ignorance. If we have truth and virtue
(are educated and loving) we move away from prejudice and pride toward
seeing everyone as intrinsically valuable, and having equal potential for
good. This increases
everyone's happiness.
Every person and group has its strengths and weaknesses. They may do poorly
what you do well, but it's equally likely that they do well what you do
poorly. Seeing ourselves as superior is simply the result of ignoring our
own flaws, failing to see others' strengths, and basing our judgment on
assets instead of virtues.
On the other hand, ideas, philosophies, opinions, beliefs, traditions,
practices, behaviors, objectives, organizations, political systems, products,
and solutions are
not fundamentally equal, or intrinsically good. Some are reliably destructive,
others have minimal impact on happiness, and some are a net benefit to
society. Regardless of our country, culture, color, or religion, the individuals
who participate in them should be evaluated on their own merits. Belonging
to a group that largely subscribes to
some destructive philosophy (as all of us do) doesn't change the value of the
individual.
We are all equal in value and infinite in potential. What we want and
choose is who we are. Our circumstances are only that. And the truth and
virtue we embrace defines our goodness, as well as our own happiness.
In light of those facts, it should be clear that inequality (in any of
its many forms) is a destructive lack of both truth and virtue and stands
in opposition to happiness. Equality is about value and virtue. Balance
and equality are not merely pleasant ideals we hope one day to achieve.
They are
achievable, and necessary to prevent destruction and to secure happiness for individuals and societies.
And they are threatened by lies and vice. People are equal. Behaviors are
not.
Unity
Why should you care about the happiness of someone other than yourself?
Two reasons (at least):
Not caring about the happiness of others is a vice that will reduce
your happiness.
Caring about others helps them be happier, and it's far better to be surrounded
by happy people than miserable ones.
We're all connected, which means your happiness benefits others, and their
happiness benefits you—just as your misery hurts others, and theirs will
hurt you. We're connected, but that doesn't mean we're automatically
united—it just makes unity that much more
important.
From subatomic particles to atoms to molecules to cells to organisms to
groups to societies, unity is about organization and purpose. It doesn't
mean that all parts are the
same. It means they work in
harmony and coordination, every part recognizing it's a piece of something larger.
It's possible, natural, and necessary for collections of diverse parts
to work together for a common good. Unity benefits from
unique individuals, but not
selfish ones.
Unity doesn't require perfection, but it
does necessitate constant effort to
deal with imperfection. Every vice threatens unity. Any part seeing any other part
as inferior (or worse, an enemy) is like a fabric unraveling itself—it
weakens the strength and beauty of the entire cloth until it all becomes
a useless pile of thread.
Those who seek to destroy, divide. Those who seek to protect, unite.
Unity is fragile. It's easily unraveled by criticism, selfishness, prejudice,
judgment, pride, extremism, and willful disregard for rules and laws designed
to preserve a state of harmony. Most of all, it's destroyed when we see
ourselves as inherently better than others. However, when we all grow in
knowledge, we're naturally unified by a common understanding of reality.
And as we develop virtue, we're unified by love, mercy, patience, open-mindedness,
and respect. Truth (especially recognizing everyone around us as our equal)
and virtue (most importantly love) are the keys to unity.
As is often the case, music provides an excellent metaphor. An orchestra
includes a wide variety of people, roles, personalities, and instruments.
Each musician has a different part to play, with a different method, sound,
level of complexity, and degree of prominence. Some are responsible for
leading, and some for following. They play in different ways, at different
times. A few have solos, but most work together. Certain pieces require
only certain instruments, but over time everyone will have been needed.
Every musician must listen to the others, play in tune (to a specific,
absolute, consistent frequency), on the beat (provided by the conductor),
and not hide behind nor drown out anyone else. There's still room for individual
and collective interpretation and musicality, but there are also predefined
limits of right or wrong. It's easy for even one individual to mar a performance,
but it's rare for anyone to do so intentionally, and there's a general
sense of sympathy and understanding when mistakes are made, as everyone
has made them. Mistakes don't constitute failure. The purpose of the orchestra
is to provide music that lifts the audience and makes life better. Every
part of the orchestra supports that mission, and achieving the best possible
performance is done through balance, equality, and unity. Only rarely does
an orchestra play the
exact same phrase or note in complete unison, and even then there's variation
in the type of sound. The unique value and benefit of an orchestra would
be destroyed by homogeneity. Different parts aligned in harmony, phrasing,
rhythm, tempo, and intonation result in an amazing unity that conveys beautiful
music with unique power.
It's hard to imagine a more perfect symbol for society. As different as
we are, we can still come together to strengthen each other and create
something beautiful. We can be our unique selves and contribute in different
ways, as long as we're unified by a set of absolute truths, consistent
virtues, and common purposes.
Society has spent so much of its existence in division and conflict that
it might be difficult to even imagine what unity would look like. But,
try. Try to picture what that would be like, and how you personally would
like to fit into that kind of community. You're different from everyone
else, and those differences can be good. They make you distinct and valuable,
with something unique and meaningful to contribute.
–
Being social by nature, we belong and [typically] thrive in groups. Groups
are complex, and individuals are unique, which makes the principles of
balance, equality, and unity challenging, but absolutely crucial. They
maximize individual and collective potential. But, complexity brings risk
and maybe even guarantee of occasional failure. We need principles that
can restore and protect balance and stability. Those are Justice and Mercy.
Chapter 4
Justice & Mercy
Hundreds of years have past since Newton described a fundamental law of
nature: for every action there's an equal and opposite reaction. Central
to that law is the fact that matter and energy are finite. What one system
takes, another loses, preserving a fundamental balance.
Recently, we've also come to understand the concept of entropy, which
describes the degree of inherent randomness in all things, the result of
which is chaos, eventually, if an organizing force isn't applied. Where
that force
is applied, the system can grow in order and complexity and usefulness. We'll
come back to those laws in a moment.
For intelligent individuals (and societies) the greatest expressions and
motivations of life are growth and happiness. Therefore, "good" is anything
that [net] contributes to that happiness and progress, and "bad" is anything
that [net] detracts from it. More benefit = more good. The double-edged
sword of community is the fact that it amplifies and connects the actions
of individuals. Every act, good or bad, will eventually affect everyone
in the community.
On the one hand, society can provide rapid accumulation of knowledge,
collective wisdom, synergies that make large or difficult tasks possible,
specializations that give individuals value and purpose, and a network
of relationships that turn our differences into strengths. It's the most
natural and beneficial arrangement of human life. On the other hand, the
destructive acts of a single individual can hurt the whole group. Differences—when
not accompanied by virtues—can lead to divisions, and lies and vice will
spread like disease through the entire community.
If we agree that happiness and growth are the fundamental purpose of society
(and of life itself), then it's important to protect anything good and
discourage anything bad. If our actions only influenced our own happiness,
or if we all recognized and corrected any imbalance we caused, a collective
response to individual action wouldn't be necessary, but our actions
can destroy balance, and a response
is necessary. Justice is the system responsible for preserving fundamental
balance, and protecting what is good. It's the immune system of society,
and one of the organizing forces that prevents chaos.
Justice
Peaceful society can only be sustained when threats against that peace
are discouraged, and destructive behaviors are stopped and corrected. Again,
if individuals fully policed their own behavior a system of justice wouldn't
be as necessary, but by nature those who most threaten a society also least
successfully control or correct their own behavior. Therefore, a justice
system
is necessary for the preservation of society.
Justice is based on laws (rules that identify what society sees as net
destructive or net benefit—like antibodies created with each new threat)
and consequences (enforcement of punishments or rewards that restore balance).
It provides the equal and opposite reaction when laws are disregarded.
That said, punishment is meant to restore balance, so it's only necessary
to the extent that natural consequences haven't already restored balance.
Cruel or excessive punishments don't restore balance. They simply swing
the pendulum back to the other side, creating a cycle of imbalance, and
imbalance is destructive—the reason why consequences should be equal, opposite,
and modified as balance requires.
When done properly, justice discourages destructive behaviors and protects
growth without creating a culture of fear. It prevents society's descent
into chaos. As intelligent beings it's our privilege—and defining characteristic—to
act more than to be acted upon, but justice is an exception when we choose
to live in a society. Accepting the benefits of community is consent for
justice to act upon us.
Justice is a fundamental human need. We understand it instinctively. Have
you ever been falsely accused or punished unfairly? Few things ignite a
stronger or more immediate indignation. A system of justice helps satisfy
that deep psychological/emotional need, creating the assurance and trust
necessary for people to live peacefully together. Punishment and reward
may not change an individual's behavior, but effective justice improves
our
collective behavior and happiness.
Our need for agency and self-driven change makes it unwise to mandate
morality, or to scare people into doing what's right, but every society
needs to identify destructive behaviors, and the weight of consequence
necessary to restore balance to society when those behaviors occur. Unfortunately,
we're all imperfect, and so is our lawmaking, law enforcement, and application
of punishment. Improper application of a justice system (cruelty, bias,
closed-mindedness or apathy, incompetence, inconsistency, weakness, etc.)
destroys the trust and growth it was meant to preserve, and
adds to the imbalance it was meant to correct. Like autoimmune disease, an
overactive or defective system causes damage to itself.
However, a healthy immune system doesn't guarantee health. A society where
the majority embraces destructive behaviors is like a body giving in to
infection in spite of its immune system—destruction being the inevitable
result.
It's often said that justice is blind. Justice applies consequence to
action. Full stop. Nothing is required for justice to do its work beyond
an accurate understanding of the action itself, and the law (consequence)
that applies to it. Justice isn't only blind—it has no memory, no feeling,
no context, no perspective. In practice, justice simply applies predetermined
consequences to predefined behaviors, regardless of context and circumstance.
So, the result of justice
alone isn't always the intended balance. It's simple, constant, universal, and
rigid, like gravity. Drop something, and it will fall to the ground. But
falling—like punishment—isn't the goal.
Birds aren't magically unaffected by gravity. They escape the usual effect
of gravity by applying other laws. Not only is that escape
possible —it's achieved by every creature or creation that applies the necessary
principles. Gravity isn't destroyed. Its negative effects are simply overcome.
Similarly, the undesirable effects (and shortcomings) of justice can be
resolved by mercy.
Mercy
Mercy is a complex system that applies many principles in harmony—not
to destroy justice, but to perfect it. Mercy provides the sight, the memory,
feeling, context, and perspective justice lacks. It provides the flexibility
necessary to keep the system from breaking. Where justice applies consequence
based on
action alone, Mercy modifies that consequence based on an understanding of the
individual and circumstance: the capacity, motives, intent, awareness, options available, upbringing,
autonomy, history, regret, consequences already suffered, and reparations
already made. Mercy acknowledges that some individuals do manage their
own behavior, and even when they fail to prevent an error they take steps
to correct the imbalance they caused. It's possible, if rare, for balance
to be fully restored without the involvement of a justice system. This
doesn't destroy justice—it fulfills the purpose for which justice exists.
Mercy is more than individualized justice. It also includes complete,
even undeserved relief. But that can only be done without destroying balance
when two conditions are met: first, justice still has to be paid in full
by
someone, and second, we have to qualify for that relief by meeting the demands
of whoever paid justice on our behalf. Qualifying for something doesn't
mean we earned or deserved it. It also doesn't mean we're completely free
of obligation. If someone else pays your debt, you aren't free of debt.
You're simply indebted to
that person, who sets the new terms. That transfer of debt and change of terms
is usually only fair if requested (or where the person can't or doesn't
know to ask).
Not only should mercy be requested—it's most effective when there's evidence
of desire to change and right the wrong, of having suffered for or corrected
the error, or of diminished accountability. Overriding justice without
justification or conditions isn't mercy—it's indulgence, permissiveness,
foolishness, and a failure to preserve the balance of society. On the other
hand,
not applying mercy where
it is justified is a greater failure. Mercy as an individual virtue (not
the social mechanism) is best applied freely, even without request, as
most of us lack the knowledge or authority to execute justice, and extending
mercy qualifies us to receive it. Sooner or later, we all need it.
Mercy keeps justice constructive and society in balance, but its greatest
benefit is individual progress. Mercy has a far greater tendency than justice
to change, improve, and ultimately stop destructive behavior. Fear of punishment
can discourage wrongdoing, but fear tends to ignite anger and rebellion,
which drives individuals away from and against society. Fear isn't a sustainable
motivator, and punishment isn't designed to improve people. Mercy, on the
other hand, is based on understanding, sympathy, empathy, and love, and
promotes a greater desire for virtue and unity in those who receive it.
Justice & Mercy
By participating in and accepting the benefits of a society we give our
implicit consent to be governed by the laws of justice and mercy of that
society. We aren't justified in pretending we owe nothing back, or that
we're somehow exempt from the demands of its system of justice. The more
we benefit from it or take its finite resources, and the more capacity
we have to give back, the greater our responsibility is. There's no logic
that justifies us in taking more than we give. Mercy protects those who
lack the
capacity to give back, but not those who lack the
will. Society is an ecosystem, and ecosystems only survive when they remain
in balance. Choosing to be a net detriment (taking more than we give, or
destroying more than we build—like parasites) only justifies society in
removing us for its own survival. Our individual truth and virtue (not
accumulated assets) allow us to be a net benefit, to avoid the demands
of justice, and to enjoy happiness ourselves.
As mentioned, virtues in isolation become vices. A virtue like justice
not tempered by a virtue like mercy becomes destructive (something illustrated
by Javert in Les Miserábles). Being imperfect people, our application of
justice and mercy will also be imperfect, but they're still critically
necessary parts of every relationship, family, and society, and perfecting
them should be a priority.
A society that understands what justice is, identifies net destructive
behaviors, determines consequences that will properly restore balance,
refines those consequences on an individual basis, then carefully applies
them or alleviates them where there's evidence of change, will have successfully
protected the pursuit of happiness. It remains the responsibility of individuals
to find happiness by governing their own behavior, seeking truth, and developing
virtue, but a just
and merciful society allows us to do so.
Achieving justice and mercy never happens by accident. Justice requires
collective acknowledgment of destructive behavior, establishment and careful
enforcement of laws, awareness of action, and active pursuit of knowledge.
Mercy requires intent, patience, open-mindedness, trust, desire to understand
unique and complex circumstances, and sometimes a willingness to assume
payment on behalf of others. They're based wholly on truth and virtue.
–
There are things we need to know, and things we need to feel to successfully
preserve balance and happiness for ourselves and our society. Thoughts
and feelings are also the definition of life experience, the fuel of memory,
and the power behind everything we do. That power is greatest when they're
combined. We need Logic
and Feeling.
Chapter 5
Logic & Feeling
Happiness, being a state of life, relies on the life-preserving attributes
of knowledge, reason, focus, action, and connection to reality. Being a
state of growth, it also requires energy, emotion, desire, motivation,
and connection. The highest state of being is more than just rational thought
or a pleasant feeling. It's a blend of understanding and feeling and being—a
marriage of logic and emotion.
Logic
Logic is the process of and metric for identifying truth. It applies what
we do know to what we don't yet understand, to help identify what is safe
to accept as truth. Logic preserves truth, wisdom, justice, and progress—and
therefore happiness—as well as the methods and tools that provide knowledge
and preserve life. It's logic and reason that enable advancements in science
and technology, that promote order and fairness, that calm and correct
destructive emotions, and that dispel lies. Logic is structured and stable,
and it
preserves structure and stability.
Logic is helpful, but limited by what we know, remember, and perceive.
Until we accurately understand, perceive, and remember
everything, our logic won't be perfect, either. But, even imperfect logic can still
be constructive. Logic doesn't hurt. More accurately, it doesn't feel at
all. It's calm, unemotional, and cerebral—but hollow. This makes it particularly
attractive to those who are tired of, afraid of, or incapable of feeling.
While escaping emotion might sound appealing, hollowness isn't happiness.
Reason is
helpful, and can eliminate many of the unnecessary troubles of life, but it's
a disappointing
replacement for happiness. Logic is exceptional at providing the
how, but not the
why. Think too hard, and you'll miss the point of everything.
Feelings
Emotion is how we experience, process, and react to reality. It also communicates
to others what we're experiencing. Virtue creates pleasant emotions (gratitude,
awe, inspiration, motivation, and love). The fresh understanding of truth
brings clarity and excitement. Positive feelings help us recognize what
is good. Vice and destruction, on the other hand, cause feelings of sadness,
disgust, repulsion, embarrassment, and frustration—unpleasant emotions
that help us consciously identify what is bad. What we feel doesn't make
us good or bad. It helps us
see what is good or bad. And we can learn to gauge how constructive or destructive
our own actions are by the way others express emotion (words, tone, and
body language). Emotions are a universal language.
In addition to communicating, feelings also motivate us to action. Feelings
like desire and conscience are the fuel that help us sustain our efforts
over the long term. Only in the absence of feeling can you appreciate the
direction and power they provide, and the paralysis they prevent. Some
things are very hard to do unless you feel strongly about them.
At a basic level, feelings help us survive. Hunger tells us when to eat,
thirst reminds us we need hydration, and exhaustion that we need to rest.
There are feelings to warn us when we get too hot or too cold, or when
we've eaten too much or too little. Feelings help us identify infection
and other conditions. Pain alerts us to injury. In general, discomfort
helps us recognize a need for change. Feelings of attraction create friendships,
partnerships, and often children. Paying attention to feelings does an
exceptional job of keeping us alive and well. Ignoring feelings ultimately
results in some of our needs not being met.
Animals migrate thousands of miles to precise locations at very specific
times, guided by instinctive impulses that help them find food, survive
weather patterns, and mate. Built-in guides are not always conscious or
logical, but they're typically accurate and beneficial. Trying to reason
our way through every part of life instead of listening to these cues creates
a mental burden that paying attention to feelings can relieve. They bring
subtle, abstract, subconscious truths to the surface where we can consciously
and constructively act on them, for our well-being.
Feelings can be helpful, but still need to be controlled
and cultivated. Regulated emotion is valuable and constructive; unmanaged,
it tends to destabilize. Even anger and fear—notoriously destructive emotions—can
be productive when managed, helping us correct problems and improve circumstances.
Managing our feelings is one of life's most difficult and constant tasks.
Some feelings should be acted on, while others should be acknowledged,
adjusted, or ignored. First, we consciously recognize and process those
feelings. Then, like taming a horse, it's a matter of controlling and mastering
(not suppressing and killing) something of great power. Once we're in control,
the difficulty subsides and we have a powerful, constructive ally.
What you feel isn't really a reflection of what you are. What you
feel may be outside your control. It's what you
do with (or in spite of) your feelings that actually matters, and that most
affects your happiness. This makes self-control one of the most constantly
essential virtues.
Cultivating feeling is as important as controlling it. Once our emotions
are managed, greater emotion adds to happiness. Increasing our capacity
to feel is facilitated by great art, religion, service, family and friendships,
and other constructive efforts. Sometimes, we just need to
allow ourselves to feel, or give ourselves time and space to feel. Managing
our own wellness unlocks clear, deep feelings based on reality.
Each feeling falls somewhere on the spectrum of physiology and consciousness.
Some, like anger, anxiety, or surprise, are deeply physical; basic biological
defaults we all tend to share. Others, like love, hope, trust, curiosity,
or edification are more subtle and complex. The state of our body and mind
tends to affect emotion, making it important to keep our body in good health.
In poor health of any kind the higher and more complex emotions become
difficult, if not impossible, to access, leaving us with only the more
basic ones—and the [correct] sense of being disconnected from reality.
When we're well we're more able to experience the entire range of emotion,
and reality itself. Health matters.
Not all feelings are constructive or tied to reality. In spite of being
real experiences themselves, some emotions are distorted by perception
or poor health. Without a healthy mind or accurate understanding of truth,
emotions can easily lead to destructive action. Being tired or hungry can
be enough. Hormones, medications, alcohol, and other substances act like
a fun-house mirror, amplifying, suppressing, and distorting our feelings.
So, acting on feelings
alone is unwise.
Without emotion we can't fully experience or understand love or peace,
suffering or conflict, progress or loss. Moderated feelings can guide us
to physical/mental/emotional health. Emotion provides energy, motivation,
desire, and the "why" of life, but doesn't help much in the "how" department.
It's a key part of experiencing happiness, but requires the moderating,
guiding structure of logic.
Logic & Feelings
Both logic
and feeling guide us toward truth. Truth is our connection to reality (past,
present, and future). Our understanding of the past is based on memory.
Memory is dependent on how clearly we understand and how deeply we feel
the present. Our understanding of the future is based on how we see the
trends and patterns of the past, and on reasonable assurances. So, logic
and feeling are our connection to all of reality.
Both logic
and feeling guide us toward virtue. Virtue is net gain, and therefore logical.
Conscience helps us feel the importance of virtue, and the feeling of happiness
confirms it.
Logic and feeling are each good at some things, and bad at others. Logic
is a terrible motivator, and emotion is a terrible decision-making strategy.
Neither achieves complete happiness on its own. It's illogical to trade
happiness for logic, just as it's foolish to trade happiness for raw emotion.
Logic isn't foolproof, and emotion isn't always constructive. But, joined
together, they enable life and a more perfect happiness. They balance,
complement, and strengthen each other. Logic moderates and guides emotion.
Emotion motivates and directs logic. Logic helps us know how to act on
feelings. Emotion is how we experience the full benefit of our logical
decisions. Together, they preserve both the
how and the
why of life.
It's common for people who prefer logic to find fault with those who prefer
emotion, and vice versa. To a mostly logical person, a more emotional one
can seem needlessly and destructively erratic. A particularly emotional
person might see a purely rational one as needlessly and destructively
cold and insensitive. And both would be right.
As is the case with all polarizations, it's a false choice. The truth
is in the middle. Not only do we
not need to choose between the two—we
should not. Both are critical to happiness, and should be developed with equal effort.
Relaxing logic enough to open our hearts is as hard as controlling emotion
enough to open our minds, but finding balance between the two is a key
to happiness.
Love
Love is one of life's most powerful feelings (love—not just sexual attraction),
and arguably one of the most logical and beneficial from nearly every perspective.
More than any other characteristic, love blends logic and emotion, truth
and virtue, to bring about personal and collective growth and happiness.
L ove isn't a single virtue. It's a collection of virtues, and at its core it's a unifying desire that
induces us to seek the well-being of others—even at the sacrifice of things
we want for ourselves. It combines selflessness, patience, generosity,
open-mindedness, tolerance, mercy, and humility. It makes us want to be
with others, to help them find happiness, to benefit from their strengths
and share ours with them. Love causes constant, willful, significant effort
to help others.
Loving relationships are mutually beneficial, empowering and protecting
those involved by sharing strengths and burdens and goals. Loving societies
would do the same. They bring happiness and growth to everyone, and eliminate
conflict and inequality.
Relationships and societies based mostly on assets (e.g. physical attraction,
power, or wealth) are parasitic—each member focused on taking what they
can, with self-interest dragging them down and driving them apart. Those
relationships decline with the assets on which they're based.
Societies built solely on the pursuit of prosperity are naturally divided
between those who have, and those who don't. When "success" means extracting
from each other as much money, land, power, praise, or advantage as possible,
the very obvious result is separation, imbalance, inequality, individualism,
conflict, and vice—the true
opposite of success. The unmoderated pursuit of wealth always leads to destructive
behavior. That's a high price for something that isn't happiness.
There's a reason we use the phrase, "fabric of society." The individual
threads of a fabric are simple and weak, but the more unified, ordered,
and interdependent those threads are, the stronger, more useful, and more
beautiful the whole fabric becomes. Rope isn't strong because of an individual
thread. The more a single strand tries to carry the whole burden, the more
likely failure becomes. It's the unification of many weak threads that
leads to strength. Unity is both logical and emotional. Unity brings strength
and order and peace, and love creates it.
Love
fixes destructive behaviors (much like mercy) by addressing the flawed motives
behind them. It doesn't just tolerate flaws—it converts them into virtues.
It unifies us in lifting us all toward more perfect behavior. Vice can
also temporarily unify (e.g., mobs, organized crime, insurrection, and
terrorism), but only to a certain extent, and never with a net effect of
happiness.
Love is as instinctive as our pursuit of happiness. It's consistently
the subject of art, music, drama, dance, literature, philosophy, religion,
commerce, and even science. We like how it makes us feel, but sometimes
forget its farther-reaching benefits. When tempered by other virtues, love
truly is the greatest single source of happiness. We can't claim we want
peace for the world until we're willing to love everyone in it.
Logic and emotion—consciously considering and constructively acting on
our feelings—is a key to happiness. It's as wise to develop logic as it
is to embrace feeling. We need both. Take time to think. Consider your
thoughts. Allow yourself to feel. Align thoughts and feelings to reality,
and moderate them with virtue. Develop love. Truth is more than logic,
and virtue more than feeling, but they work harmoniously, unlocking the
capacity to fully experience true happiness.
–
At this point you likely are or should be wondering, "but what about [x,
y, or z]?" It's certainly true there are exceptions. We aren't all the
same. Identity and personality aside, our circumstances can be radically
different. Unusual though they may be, it's important to try to understand
those circumstances both for the benefit of those suffering through them,
and for ourselves (as we may eventually find ourselves in the same situation).
We have the most to learn from what is most confusing, and few things are
more confusing than Circumstances and Exceptions.
Chapter 6
Circumstances & Exceptions
Knowing principles gives you the ability to understand, predict, and influence
what's around you. Knowledge
is power, and principles are the most powerful kind of knowledge—the rules
and patterns of life. Principles like truth and virtue are central to happiness,
and the vast majority of the time they work as expected, but sometimes,
for some people (maybe for you) the outcome may appear to be different.
Truth is consistent by definition, so whatever seems like inconsistency
in a true principle is actually something else. It's usually an uncommon
or unfamiliar collision of realities (other principles and circumstances)
that causes the unexpected outcome. That it was unexpected means there's
something we didn't understand. If we don't understand the exceptions,
we don't fully understand the principle. The better you understand the
exceptions the better you can prepare, set reasonable expectations, and
help others.
Bodies are our most constant and probably most complicated circumstance.
When you consider the number of cells, tissues, and systems that have to
work properly for you to be in good health, it's a miracle any of us ever
are. The more parts a system has, the more probable it is that one will
fail. Bodies
tend to work well, but in their vast complexity, surrounded by countless environmental
variables, failure happens. That can be as simple as a mole on your arm,
or as serious as death. Some of our choices influence how reliable our
bodies will be, but external circumstances beyond our control can, too.
When we're completely healthy we have control over our decisions, more
control over our circumstances, and principles like truth and virtue will
usually just work. When we're
not well, our perception, energy, and ability to act and change can be very
limited. Experiences that are normal for others can become impossible for
us. We may not be able to feel, focus, or remember. It's like being shut
out of life—a barrier between what
we experience, and what
everyone else appears to experience. That feeling of isolation is difficult, but there's
hope. Learning to understand exceptions can bring peace to you, if you're
the one experiencing them, or capacity to help, if you're not. Either way,
understanding the effect of circumstances and exceptions on well-being
and happiness is a key.
Circumstance
Circumstance is current reality. It's everything in and around us that
acts on us. Being intelligent beings, we can make decisions and change
some of those circumstances, but others remain outside our control. Some of
our circumstances come from our own past actions. Most are either natural,
or the effects of
other people's actions. Our genetics are a circumstance into which we are born.
The weather is a natural circumstance. The opportunities and resources
available to us, the peace or conflict surrounding us are circumstances—things
we may be able to influence, but only to the extent
other circumstances permit.
They say life isn't fair, which requires very little power of observation.
Looking only at the relatively short period from birth to death, and how
different our life experiences are, it's hard to argue otherwise. Some
people work multiple jobs most of their life to just scrape by. Some can't
work at all. Some endure life-long pain, abuse, war, injustice, and/or
deprivation. Another portion of this world is born into freedom, safety,
health, wealth, loving families, and communities that provide every opportunity.
Everyone starts life with a different set of cards. We're all affected
differently by opportunity and catastrophe, but while circumstance
affects us all, it
defines none of us.
Our minds are wired to look for patterns in life, which helps us survive
and progress. Life can be chaotic, and chaos means uncertainty, which we
don't like. Patterns help us find order and predictability. But we're also
wired to pay attention to
variations in patterns. Our eyes are drawn to whatever is out of place, or unexpected.
We pay attention when someone does something out of character. If you saw
someone with three eyes, you'd remember it. Principles are the patterns
of reality. Exceptions are deviations from those patterns that reveal more
complex realities—and the need to
try to understand the principles involved.
The Bell Curve
Most circumstances still fall within reach of happiness, but on the extremes
there are exceptions. You may already be familiar with the bell curve—the
visual representation of a pattern in life: that average is not just roughly
in the
middle of the extremes—it's also more
common. Extremes being more rare, the curve starts low on one end, rises in
the middle (like a bell), and drops down again on the high end. This observation
applies to countless parts of life—happiness being one of them.
Looking at all of humanity, there aren't many who are utterly, constantly
miserable, and similarly few who would claim to be perfectly, constantly
happy. The majority of us are somewhere in the middle. However, the bell
curve also indicates something important: few though they might be, there
still
are people on the extremes. Their exceptional circumstances deserve attention—both
as a reminder for us to offer help to those at the bottom, and an opportunity
to learn from the fortunate few at the top.
Attribution Flaw
We all fail, sometimes. Life is complicated, and none of us are perfect.
That
should make us less quick to criticize, but responding appropriately to failure
(or success) and learning from it is often sabotaged by a human default:
blaming our own failings on
circumstance, and the failings of others on flawed
character. At the same time, we chalk up our own successes to good
character, and the successes of others to
circumstance. For example:
" I'm late to class because I was stuck behind a slow car on a one-lane road.
You're late to class because you don't care, and don't ever leave early enough
to get anywhere on time."
" I'm on time because I'm careful and organized.
You're on time because you live closer, have more reliable transportation, or
someone reminded you."
" I'm poor because of low wages, catastrophe, injustice, etc.
You're poor because you're lazy, foolish, and bad with money."
" I'm rich because I was smart and hardworking and prepared.
You're rich because of luck, being in the right place at the right time, or inheriting
wealth."
Beyond the terrible irony, this pattern of thinking fails to produce happiness
or harmony because it's a disconnect from truth. It doesn't acknowledge
the fact that
truth is in the middle —that we
all succeed or fail because of a
combination of character
and circumstance. Those who are wealthy and those who are poor, those who
are well-educated and those who are ignorant, those who win and those who
lose, all have those outcomes because of some combination of
both character and circumstance. The ability to work hard means you were fortunate
enough to have sufficient mental, emotional, and/or physical health (a
circumstance). Being in the right place at the right time can also be the
result of wise preparation and patiently seeking out opportunity (virtue).
We should never be too proud of our own accomplishments, too dismissive
of others', too quick to offload the responsibility for our failures, or
too willing to judge others for theirs. Virtue is less visible than assets
and circumstance, so it's a bad idea to judge others (in general, but certainly
by just what we see with our eyes).
Though outcomes are caused by both circumstance
and character, that split isn't 50/50. Circumstance has more impact on assets.
Character has more impact on happiness. Circumstance can be overpowering
(mental illness, brain damage, environmental factors, injury, bad information,
catastrophe, war, unjust and broken systems, etc.), so our outcomes are
often a poor indication of our efforts and character. On the other hand,
we can usually develop a strength of character that enables us to be and
do good in spite of circumstance, and find happiness regardless of our
assets.
Well-being
You're a complex being made of cells, tissues, organs, and systems, each
with its own needs. But, those needs are connected. Every part of you is
interdependent. One system failing can cause the rest to fail. So, well-being
isn't compartmentalized. Your physical well-being is connected to your
mental, emotional, and all other types of well-being.
We share most of the same needs: warmth, nutrition and clean water, rest,
care, love, security… Simple things. In a functional society, those needs
should be easily met. What we collectively have (when combined with concern
for one another and a bit of ingenuity) is enough. The fact that we've
failed for so long in our efforts to achieve universal well-being—the main
objective of society—points to a deficit not so much of resources, but
of truth, virtue, and will.
Well-being isn't all there is to happiness, but it
is a prerequisite because happiness is based on progress, and progress requires
that our needs be met. Needs are needs
because they are required for life and growth, and not having them results in
damage or destruction. A plant won't grow without adequate light, water,
and minerals. You won't grow, either, unless your specific needs are met
(wants are a different story, so it's wise to perceive the difference).
There are lower needs and higher needs, and we struggle to think beyond
our most basic unmet need (it's hard to climb a ladder that's missing the
bottom rungs). Our thoughts and emotions are impacted by our state of wellness.
If we aren't well, our focus naturally shifts from the long-term
purpose of life to the short-term
preservation of life—a reasonable re-prioritization. When you fall off a boat, you
don't worry too much about getting to your destination on time, or what
you're going to wear. Not drowning is good enough. A person in survival
mode isn't as capable of the clear, rational, outward, long-term thought
necessary for happiness and growth. Desperation kicks in, then reinforces
itself by limiting our ability to make wise choices. Crisis can rob us
of options, energy, autonomy, and progress. And for some, crisis is a permanent
state of life.
Need can make us dependent on others. Whether or not society caused the
circumstances leading to that desperation (which it sometimes does), it
benefits both society and the individual for everyone to pitch in and help
address the unmet needs. The basic idea of society is that we
share burdens and strengths for the benefit of all. When someone falls off our boat, pointing fingers
is far less helpful than extending a hand, and saving one person helps
everyone. Well-being requires that we help each other.
It's our individual responsibility to prevent and overcome personal crises
to the extent we can, but we all
want to avoid them, and they happen anyway. It's foolish, destructive, and
usually unfair to blame the victim. Even when the victim
is at fault, the poor outcomes are often punishment enough. Suffering is
an effective object lesson. Helping those who need and want help is key
to greater well-being in the future. Often enough, crisis is caused by
one person, and experienced by another.
Well-being is intertwined with physical health. Health is an asset, so
we don't have total control over it. We can be born with or without it,
successfully develop it or have it taken away. Poor mental, emotional,
or physical health limit our capacity to grow in truth or virtue, and can
destroy our ability to experience emotion at all. Most of us do have control
over our health, and it's a tragedy when we willingly throw that away through
poor nutrition, inadequate sleep, lack of exercise, chemical dependency,
and other needlessly risky or damaging activities. Taking care of our bodies
doesn't only
extend our life. It enables us to achieve and experience happiness—to live a
better life.
Financial well-being is also an asset and circumstance. As long as money
remains a part of society, it will affect our survival, and too little
will trigger survival mode and its self-perpetuating spiral of desperation.
Unlike health, however, there's a finite quantity of money in the world
(a fact that gives money its value in the first place). That means that
what one person gains, someone else loses, and simply creating more devalues
what
everyone has. So, the moment we take more than we need is the moment we start to
cause deprivation for others, unless and until we've guaranteed everyone's
needs are met first. Blaming the poor for their poverty ignores [at the
very least] this fact that money is finite. There isn't enough for everyone
to have what the wealthiest have—regardless of effort or cleverness. Sharing
is fundamental to collective well-being.
As long as society requires money to meet basic needs, the responsibility
of correcting inequality will fall primarily on those who possess more
than they need. Giving up what we have but don't need is a small sacrifice
with huge benefits. And those do it attest to the happiness it creates
(for themselves and others).
The infinite capacity and potential happiness of humanity relies on wellness—and
consequently our willingness to take care of ourselves and each other.
Exceptions
Principles help you understand what to expect, but there are always exceptions.
Recipes
tend to work, but variables (like bacteria, humidity, temperature, air pressure,
method, or time) can change the outcome, even if you follow the recipe
exactly. Underlying health conditions and genetics affect the effects of
exercise. A standard method or technique may not work for someone with
physical limitations. Gravity pulls most things downward, but bubbles,
balloons, thermals, and other things less dense than their immediate surroundings
will be pushed upward, not because gravity is a big fat lie, but because
its effects are relative and sometimes overpowered by other laws. Exceptions
aren't the failure of a principle—just the intersection of multiple principles.
When someone if affected differently by natural laws it would certainly
be strange and flawed to assume that unchangeable, universal principles
have suddenly, arbitrarily stopped working, or only apply to certain people.
It's more accurate (and more constructive) to recognize those variations
as an indication of other forces at play, and an opportunity to better
understand them.
We don't enjoy confusion, so we often close our minds to anything confusing.
But, exceptions are important to understand because we will eventually
find ourselves affected by them. When that happens—when happiness suddenly
seems impossible, or truth and virtue appear unreliable, maintaining proper
perspective becomes difficult. We can survive difficult circumstances and
even turn them into an opportunity for growth if we remember a few facts:
Perception isn't the same as reality
True principles don't change
Life isn't homogeneous
You're never as alone as you feel
Circumstances don't define worth or happiness
There's a reason and season for everything
Perception isn't the same as reality
The state of your mind or your emotional and physical health can dramatically
impact your ability to experience many parts of life—from sights, sounds,
and smells to emotions, motivations, and happiness itself.
It doesn't mean they're not there, but you may lack the ability to perceive them as others do.
There's a wide spectrum of wellness between those who are "whole," and
those who are not—between people who enjoy mental clarity, emotional self-sufficiency,
physical strength, and boundless energy, and those who are disconnected
from reality, emotionally ill, physically limited, and suffering chronically
from pain and other exhausting challenges. Being on the bottom end of the
wellness spectrum means that principles of happiness may seem to not work
at all. Again,
not because the principles are untrue, but because those exceptional circumstances
so thoroughly impact our ability to perceive and experience emotion, progress,
focus, love, or energy—the facets of happiness. We do instinctively know
that happiness is the point of life, so it's when we don't experience happiness
or love that we start to question if there's a point.
Enjoying abnormally easy, unimpeded progress and happiness is the other
uncommon extreme. For those on this end of the wellness spectrum, everything
just seems to work, making it easy for them to fall prey to the false perception
that life is just as easy for everyone else—and that unhappiness must be
the result of character flaw. Either extreme can distort our perception.
True principles don't change
Truth is unchangeable, but one true principle can be overridden by another,
just as gravity's effects are overcome by the principles that enable flight.
Sometimes familiar principles are overpowered to our benefit, and at other
times to our detriment. We crave justice, while it's in our favor, but
eventually we hope mercy will overpower it. True principles are invincible
and constant—which makes them so valuable to understand—but they do interact
with one another. The complex dynamics between principles can create unusual
circumstances.
Life isn't homogeneous
The world is complex, and full of variety. That makes life hard to predict—but
also interesting and fulfilling. If everyone were like you, would there
be any benefit in your existence, or value in meeting someone new? If every
part of the world looked the same, would there be any joy in traveling?
If every food were the same, would it provide much pleasure?
Similarly, every part of life will be a bit different. Expect change.
Much of it will be good. Some of it will seem impossibly hard. At some
point you'll feel out of place, or that life is unfair. Both may be true.
It can also feel like principles aren't real and happiness is impossible.
Both are
un true. People are also not homogeneous, so we collectively possess a variety
of strengths and weaknesses that allow us to help each other through the
randomness of life—through the variations that make life meaningful and
beautiful, though sometimes difficult.
You're never as alone as you feel
In a world with billions of people, you're never as alone or unique in
your experiences as you may feel, regardless of how understanding and empathetic
the people immediately around you may [or may not] be. Statistically speaking,
someone, somewhere, at some time has probably experienced what you are
now experiencing, or something very similar—and others likely will in the
future. Seeking out those who have experienced and learned from circumstances
like ours can help. Leaving behind a record of our own experience and lessons
learned will help someone else. You are
unique, but you're never
alone, even in the most exceptional circumstances.
Circumstances don't define worth or happiness
Circumstance doesn't fully guarantee any specific outcome—good
or bad. We're all impacted by circumstance, and it's
choice that most affects our long-term outcomes. Ice may send you off the road,
snow may slow you down, traffic may cause delays, construction may reroute
you, but determination and patience will all but ensure you still arrive
at your destination. The happiness we ultimately achieve is due to our
choices, in spite of circumstance.
Placing someone in a situation does not cause them to
be anything in particular. From one situation you may have as many outcomes
as people you put into it. Human nature tends to be consistent, but our
unique desires and choices can override our natural defaults, leading to
an endless array of results that reveal what we really are. Our will is
our identity. Our circumstances are just circumstances.
Worth and happiness are
internal, so they're most affected by what is internal. The more knowledge and
virtue you have, the less your happiness is influenced by anything else.
There's a reason and season for everything
We experience day and night, summer and winter. They happen because the
earth spins, is slightly tipped, and goes around the sun. The kind of day
or season you experience depends on your unique position on the earth.
The kind of life we have will also be different from anyone else's, because
of where and what we are. Our circumstances are intersecting ripples of
natural laws and countless conscious decisions (not just our own).
We all have seasons of peace and growth, and periods of difficulty and
loss. The changing-but-cyclical nature of life guarantees a time for everything—being
normal or exceptional, successful or struggling. It brings challenges as
well as hope. Winter doesn't last forever. Some struggles seem like they
will never end, but they can still be full of growth, learning, love, and
meaning. And there will be a time to enjoy the benefits of lessons painfully
learned. Circumstances change, and if you choose to change as well (to
progress), then those changes can lead to greater happiness. As challenging
and unchangeable as your past may be, the future is still impressionable.
Experiencing exceptions is the best way to develop understanding of overriding
principles, and grow in empathy for others with similar circumstances,
and to overcome judgmentalism. Our brains are wired to pay attention to
changes in a pattern, so we don't waste energy analyzing why the sun came
up again this morning, but we'd put all our energy into figuring out why
it didn't. Exceptional circumstances force us to stretch our minds, invest
our energy, and develop an understanding of principles we might otherwise
have ignored. This is an opportunity to grow in truth and virtue. It makes
us capable of aiding those who currently find themselves struggling for
survival and understanding, which in turn increases their happiness and
our own. When struggling on the fringes ourselves we don't usually seek
out the companionship of those who have breezed through life without difficulty.
Instead, we crave the support and wisdom of a person who understands and
has experienced our pain. Without feeling pain ourselves, we can never
be that person for someone else. We can't
give happiness, but we
can give support, improve the circumstances of those in need, and aid in their
well-being.
A life that doesn't deviate at all from our expectations, hopes, dreams,
plans, or comfort zone will also fail to provide the deeper benefits of
experience, understanding, empathy, joy, resilience, and progress that
come from circumstances we wouldn't seek. Carrying weight is uncomfortable,
unpleasant, and exhausting, but it's the only way to grow stronger. Uncertainty
can be scary, but venturing into the unknown and unplanned is the only
place where discovery is ever made. Suffering perfects us in ways that
only suffering can. When painful circumstances come we can choose to give
in to self pity and despair, or we can draw from the bottomless spring
of hope and turn those experiences into growth that provides deep empathy
and durable happiness.
The incredible breadth of human experience makes life much more worth
living. It encompasses unimaginable pain, as well as deep joy. A small
part will be familiar. A larger part will be normal. But all of it, with
it's challenges and rewards, is there for us to learn—to experience for
ourselves and through others. You may find yourself on the fringe, but
you are still part of the swirling, dynamic whole of humanity, and will
find yourself where others have been, just as others will find themselves
some day in your shoes. Circumstances from the perspective of individuals
may look like insurmountable problems. In the broader context of society,
they are completely manageable issues; natural variations in a larger pattern.
Circumstances are simply
where you are, not
who you are. Giving and accepting help is the purpose of community.
Don't underestimate the power of circumstances and exceptions to teach
truth and virtue. There's little in life that provides a better opportunity
for growth in understanding, empathy, love, and ultimately happiness. Perfecting
and purifying is always a harsh process, but it's worth the pain. We don't
need to seek out or add to our own struggles—life seems to provide a full
dose of suffering on its own—but for the sake of everyone's progress, we
should watch for and help those who find themselves outside the realm of
happiness.
If you are the one living an exception and fighting against circumstance,
just keep going. Trust in principles: in truth and virtue. Learn what you
can from your current perspective, and lend a hand to the many others who
need that perspective. Accept help.
Ask for help. Others need to give it as much as you need to receive it. You
may not see or feel it now, but you'll be getting closer to happiness,
and helping others do the same.
There's no way to build a boat that guarantees good weather, so we build
boats to
survive any kind of weather. Truth and virtue don't eliminate challenges, but
they give you the power to come out on top. Just hang on, and do your best.
–
Empathy is learning to feel what others feel, and caring like you're experiencing
what they are. Difficult and exceptional circumstances, as unpleasant as
they are, are uniquely good at helping us understand and empathize. When
you're suffering, it's much more comforting to receive support from someone
who has suffered in the same way—to feel
understood. Suffering gives you the power to offer that kind of comfort, and provide
hope.
Hope can be hard to sustain because we need it most in times of difficulty,precisely
when suffering narrows our vision, drains us of energy, and causes us to
fear the future. But, hopelessness is destructive, and therefore wrong.
What is there to hope for? Where do we find the energy and patience to
hope in the face of suffering, poor circumstances, and failure? That's
the subject of Faith and God.
Chapter 7
Faith & God
At some point in our journey to knowledge and virtue we crash into the
hard reality that we simply can't go far enough on our own. There are things
we can't do or change, even as a group. Sometimes, we can't find the truth,
achieve wellbeing, alter our circumstances, change our behaviors, or fix
what we've broken. We're not yet perfect, after all. But, there's hope
for happiness, even while we're short on knowledge and virtue. It has to
do with faith.
The word "faith," like the word "happiness," has been used so loosely
its meaning may not be clear. In a broad sense, faith is an assurance that
leads to action. Justified trust, in other words. In the same way that
logic helps us trust certain information based on what we've already learned,
faith helps us trust certain things based on what we've already experienced.
Assurance comes from past experience (truth), and confidence in people
(because of their virtue). Getting out of bed every morning is an act of
faith—a confidence that the effort will be worth it, supported by other
successful adventures in getting out of bed. Every effort is based on hope
or expectation of future benefits. Everyone has this kind of faith, and
uses it daily. The future is uncertain, making faith a fundamental part
of life.
We might have faith in the laws of nature, faith in systems or institutions,
faith in things we've created and those who created them, faith in the
people around us, or faith in ourselves. We put our lives in the hands
of others on a constant basis because of that trust. Driving a car requires
trust in those who designed, built, tested, regulated, sold, and trained
us to use it, trust in the roads and those who create and maintain them,
trust in our own ability to pilot the vehicle safely, trust in transit
laws to produce safety, trust in those around us to not break those laws,
and even a general trust that the effort of driving the vehicle to our
destination will produce some benefit. Every act requires faith. The greater
the task, the more faith is required. The greater the faith, the easier
that effort becomes.
Trust is often broken. People (including ourselves), products, or systems
can fail. We don't always see the expected benefits. That can lead to doubt,
distrust, fear, a lack of confidence, and an unwillingness to take healthy
risks. It might even seem wise to
not have faith, but here's why it isn't. First, faith is required for
any action. Second, acts of doubt, fear, distrust, uncertainty, indecisiveness,
and hesitancy consistently produce poor results. Faith isn't only fundamental
to life. It's inherently good. Greater trust results in greater growth
and happiness, which in turn reinforces that trust and creates a positive
feedback loop. When people are trusted it encourages them to become more
trustworthy. Doubt and distrust are also self-reinforcing, destructive,
and consequently wrong. So, a key to happiness is
choosing to have faith, and to trust.
We usually have to choose between trusting what isn't perfect, or not
trusting at all. That said, the more perfect a person, product, or system
is, the greater the assurance and faith it can produce—and therefore confidence,
trust, energy, and willingness to act. The full benefit of faith only comes
when it's based on something (or someone) perfect.
God
Any thorough discussion of truth and virtue is bound to land on the subject
of God, the being believed by much of humanity to be the source and embodiment
of both truth and virtue (not to mention the creator of all things).
Happiness is the point of life, so anything that significantly affects
our happiness matters. That means the topic of God's existence is an important
one. It affects our daily decisions, our faith, and our hope, all of which
determine the trajectory of our life and therefore our eventual degree
of happiness. Whether or not we believe in a god matters, and the
kind of god in which we believe also matters.
Assuming that intelligent life's most fundamental motivation is happiness,
and that the accumulation of truth and virtue leads to happiness and ultimately
the growth and perfection of individuals and societies, it's reasonable
to assume any real god would be the result of that kind of process. A perfect
being would have progressed like all other intelligent life, from an imperfect
state, to a state of perfect power and happiness through the gathering
of knowledge and the development of virtue.
Considering the progress we've made over the just the last hundred years
in the advancement of maths, science, medicine, engineering, art, communication,
and access to information (in spite of our imperfection), it's easy to
imagine a time in the not-so-distant future when humanity will have achieved
the ability to travel to other worlds and populate them with its own creations.
And if
we have the potential to do it, a more perfect society would be even more
capable of it. It's a small logical step to imagine a being sufficiently
perfect to have created and populated this earth. And the intent of that
effort—the motivation of any being full of truth and virtue—would be happiness.
If you had assurance (through some form of evidence) of a god's reality
and of their perfect nature, you'd also be able to rely with complete faith
on any communication from them as a shortcut to happiness. They could have
observed the lives of countless individuals over countless years, so their
perspective would be perfect and priceless, and disregarding it would be
foolish. It's reasonable to assume that a god would communicate the principles
we're ready to receive and implement, but not more than we can handle.
Faith being constructive, that would mean less proof than we're inclined
to want, but enough to progress toward greater truth, virtue, and happiness
(and more as we become ready for it). Simply knowing we have a perfectly
loving, all-knowing, all-powerful ally would bring hope, peace, and confidence—to
the extent that we align ourselves to them.
Whether or not you believe in a god, having a clear understanding of truth,
virtue, wisdom, justice, mercy, balance, equality, logic, emotion, and
circumstance will give you a standard by which you can gauge what a god
would be like, and judge between our conflicting perceptions of god. Why
should we attempt such a thing? Because it helps identify truth. Because
those conflicting [and therefore not wholly accurate] opinions about god
have driven thousands of years of war, conflict, suffering, despair, and
destruction. That's certainly not the intent or will of any real god, whose
efforts would be focused on the happiness, unity, and growth of mankind.
They are the natural and obvious result of our own willful ignorance and
vice —the usual source of destruction and misery.
If there's a god—an eternal, all-knowing, all-powerful creator—they'd
understand happiness. They'd
be happy, so they'd work to support our happiness. That means preserving
our freedom, and teaching, promoting, encouraging, and reminding us of
truth and virtue. They'd know that happiness is internal and the result
of knowledge gained and virtue developed through personal experience, because
they'd have acquired truth and virtue in the same way. They'd provide us
with the conditions necessary for growth and learning: opportunity to invest
and sacrifice, challenges to strengthen us and help us learn from and rely
on one another with empathy, and the chance to practice making decisions—even
destructive ones—for our own improvement, knowing that bad things happening
to good people doesn't permanently prevent actual happiness.
Such a being wouldn't value one person or group more than another, but
would judge and favor us based on our desires, and the truth and virtue
we develop, instead of assets amassed. They wouldn't often insert themselves
in our lives without our consent, but would help wisely upon request (like
a parent, not a vending machine). And they'd organize those who listen
to them into a system of balance, equality, and unity. In short, we'd expect
more or less what we see in the world today: a life of freedom to choose
how to act and what to believe, guided toward happiness by witnesses and
records, where destruction remains the natural result of ignorance and
vice, but happiness remains available (in spite of circumstance) to all
who prioritize knowledge and virtue over immediate gratification, and who
ask for help.
A god would have encouraged organizations for the careful distribution
of truth, the care of those in need, and the peace and security of society
(families, church, and government)—unity and happiness being the typical
result. And, thanks to the vice common in mankind, we should expect to
see alternatives pop up that align not with reality, but the beliefs and
ambitions of those who created them (individualism, abuses, philosophies,
extremism, secretive organizations, false religions, and manipulative forms
of government), with conflict and misery being the natural consequence.
We would also expect a perfect, eternal being to have created mankind
to have the possibility of infinite potential (hope of eternal growth being
a facet of perfect happiness). And humanity, to the extent it gives in
to misunderstandings and self-centeredness, would mischaracterize and blame
that being for any unpleasantness that crops up in the meantime, and imagine
false gods more like us—imperfect, selfish, domineering, warring, vengeful,
fickle beings who toy with mankind and needlessly inflict suffering—in
other words: convenient scapegoats for our own flaws and failures. No real
god would manage earth with human-like autocracy and foolishness.
A true god (a perfect being) would encourage freedom, responsibility,
and decision making based on long-term growth and happiness rather than
immediate reward. It would be reasonable to expect they would provide a
way for us to advance to their state of perfection and immortality if we
wanted it, making the long-term reward for constructive action infinitely
greater. They would prioritize our eternal happiness over our immediate
happiness (seeing short-term suffering as a necessary and relatively tiny
part of our complete existence). This eternal-perspective accounting would
compensate for the seemingly absurd discrepancies in humankind's current
peace, prosperity, and opportunity.
In short, an imperfect, unhappy world can't reasonably be blamed on a
god, and only proves how much
we still have to learn, and how much help we need.
Suffering
Polishing is the act of grinding down. Purification involves intense heat,
corrosive chemicals, or pressure. The process of becoming better, stronger,
and more useful is usually intense. While most of us would prefer to not
suffer, it's what seems to improve us most. Nothing produces more understanding,
sympathy, and empathy than suffering. Nothing in life makes us more grateful
for what we have than loss. Nothing humbles us more than failure. Nothing
reminds us of our need for others or provides opportunity for service like
a crisis. Being deprived of resources teaches us to prioritize and share.
In the face of destruction we finally self-evaluate with complete honesty.
Suffering makes us patient, strong, empathetic, aware of others, and of
our own flaws and needs, and therefore more connected and humble and useful—when we allow it to. The lessons learned from suffering over time lead to wisdom. If you
want to be better, that's the effect suffering will have. If you want to
be
bitter, it can facilitate that for you as well. The result is determined by
what you want (who you choose to be).
You
can choose to develop virtue with or without suffering, and those who choose
to serve and spend time around the less fortunate can learn a great deal
from
their suffering. But, we aren't always that wise. Suffering, it seems, teaches
us what we wouldn't choose to learn on our own. Few things bring truth
and virtue more quickly. We may
enjoy blue skies, but all lands with uninterrupted blue skies are deserts. Rain
brings life and growth.
Ease and comfort aren't
wrong, but they don't do much for our progress or happiness. A tree protected
from wind won't develop its full strength or depth. A muscle or bone deprived
of resistance becomes fragile. A mind that isn't challenged doesn't grow.
People protected from work, failure, or struggle lack strength, depth,
endurance, understanding, and empathy. We
want uninterrupted comfort, but not the
effects of uninterrupted comfort. That's a disconnect from reality—one we need
to fix.
But, suffering and misery aren't synonymous (nor are happiness and pleasure).
Misery is a destructive state, a corruption and reduction of life, and the
result of destructive thoughts and acts. Suffering is a temporary circumstance,
and provides the perfect conditions for discovering the most valuable kinds
of knowledge and virtue—and eventually happiness. There's no need to seek
out pain—life usually provides as much as we need—but suffering is key
to avoiding misery.
It's not that bad things happen to good people, any more than heavy things
happen to strong people. It's that all kinds of things happen to all kinds
of people, and suffering helps
produce good people. Weight leads to strength. To some extent, it's causation,
not correlation.
The age-old debate about why a god might cause or permit suffering reveals
a fundamental misunderstanding about suffering, happiness, and godhood.
That complaint (typically
not an actual, honest question) assumes that suffering is a net loss. It assumes
that happiness and suffering are opposites. And it assumes that a god permitting
suffering means they're unjust and unkind. It isn't, they're not, and they
can't be. If happiness is the point of life, any god would be happy, and
would want our happiness. Suffering, effective as it is at producing knowledge
and virtue, would be a natural part of that effort. No god would deprive
us of that vehicle for growth or be foolish enough to always give us what
we want (though they might intervene as needed), nor would they make us
do what they want (which
would limit suffering—but also progress). Suffering is a temporary side-effect
of our very necessary freedom of choice.
Beyond the natural benefits of suffering, perfect justice would also require
compensation for those who suffer for reasons other than their own choices.
If part of us is eternal, that reward could come at any future time (making
faith more necessary, and suffering more beneficial).
Whether suffering affects our faith in a god, or our happiness, is up
to us. It's really not a question of logic. It's just a choice. We all
suffer, then we all choose what to make of it. What effect do you want
it to have?
–
We can judge the value of any belief or behavior by its net contribution
to the happiness of humanity. The world's religions disagree on many points,
and are therefore not all correct, but as always, we can look to overlap—to
the absolute center—for the most accurate truths. Most acknowledge the
existence of a god in some form, and the value of virtue (some version
of the Golden Rule). Faith in a
perfect god is the most logical and beneficial, and only those who believe in
that kind of god can maximize happiness. Only a perfect god can provide
hope of loving help, perfect justice, and absolute truth. Those who believe
in a vengeful, discriminatory god will deprive themselves of hope, and
justify themselves in being vengeful and discriminatory themselves (and
in the process, make themselves miserable).
Belief in a perfect, eternal god leads naturally to belief in immortality
and life beyond death, which elevates behavior to the most selfless and
constructive kinds of action. It enables us to do good right now without
expecting reward right now. Whether or not you exert that degree of faith,
we all benefit from and owe something to those who improve society without
expecting reward
from society (just from god at some point after their death). It brings them
satisfaction, and facilitates everyone else's well-being and happiness.
That makes this kind of belief productive and objectively good. It's also
logical and quite possibly true.
Few sources of sadness or pain are greater than the loss of loved ones,
so it's hard to think of an idea with a greater potential impact on our
happiness than life after death—particularly one in which we are reunited
with our loved ones. It's equally difficult to imagine an idea that causes
more despair, hopelessness, and apathy, or that encourages more destructive,
short-sighted, self-gratifying behavior than the belief that death is the
end of our existence. The concept that some part of us is eternal and survives
beyond death (and existed before birth) is central to hope and faith and
happiness (not to mention identity, agency, purpose, sacrifice, justice,
etc.). It's supported by the frequent conflict between our deepest will
and what our body wants, what we want to be, and currently are. It's also
in line with the unusually common experience many have (even those who
don't believe in a life after this one) of interaction with a deceased
loved one, or an out-of-body experience. There's reason to believe we're
more than just our body, and that part of us will continue to exist. That's
a key to happiness—and to understanding ourselves and the rest of reality.
When boiled down, the promise of faith is a greater and more lasting happiness
than we could otherwise achieve. Every person has a limit to the progress
they can make on their own—a limit to the truth they can find, the virtue
they can develop, and the needs they can meet. There's only so much we
can do to change the consequences of past decisions, or ensure justice.
Faith and god remove that limitation, and provide hope in a more perfect,
permanent progress and happiness than our natural capacity permits. You
can find a degree of happiness on your own, but complete happiness requires
faith in a perfect being,
and hope in life after this one. Happiness being the objective of life, it's
wise to give those concepts a full and fair chance.
Whether or not you find the concept of religion appealing, or have valid
reason to distrust [supposedly] religious figures or organizations, the
underlying promise of religion is still reasonable. There are many accounts
of interaction with god throughout history, and currently billions of individual
believers. That volume of evidence deserves serious consideration. It
is logical. How to know with
certainty is a subject for another book, but the most obvious and reasonable solution
when you want to know something is to ask. Just don't throw out the baby
with the bathwater.
Religion and Science
It's a tragedy that science and religion have remained at odds for thousands
of years. Science has positioned itself as "defender of truth," and religion
has claimed the role of "defender of virtue." Science has pursued objective,
measurable truth, clinging to logic, often with an ironic closed-mindedness
toward anything emotional, unseen, self-evident, or that can't be determined
with a process science established.
Religion has proclaimed [and with great irony, violently defended] virtue
and embraced emotion and belief, frequently at the expense of logic or
even obvious truth when it appeared in some way to be in conflict with
perceived "doctrine" (ask Galileo or Socrates for information on this subject).
Both science and religion are practiced by people, so both are plagued
by vice and inaccuracy. Both have pieces of truth, but resist truth from
the other. The greatest skeptics of God tend to be pro-science, and the
most closed-minded deniers of scientific discovery tend to be religious
zealots. The polarization of science and religion has done exactly what
polarization always does—divides people into groups that have only a diminishing
portion of the truth and virtue, which then leads to conflict (in this
case, thousands of years of mutual persecution).
Science would be improved if it embraced true religion, and religion would
improved if it embraced well-supported science. They would both encourage
faith for the meaningful action it generates, and condemn the corrosive
vice from which both have suffered. Ultimately, the two would no longer
be distinct, and the pursuit of truth so natural and integral to life it
wouldn't even need a name. Society would be unified in a clear understanding
of what is right
and good, and consequently a much greater capacity for growth and happiness.
Truth and virtue together create what ought to be created, and destroy
what ought to be destroyed.
If this book achieves only one thing, it should be to convince everyone
that truth is truth regardless of its source, virtue is inherently constructive,
all people are people, and well-being matters. Science and religion are completely
compatible and necessary, because our goal is not just knowledge
or faith, but the fusion of
all correct and good things, which leads to a state of happiness. At their
core, science and religion are already the same thing: people seeking growth
through observation, recording, and analysis. What we observe and record,
how accurate our conclusions are, and what we do with that information
can vary, but the concept is the same. We become happier as we learn from
experience.
–
Life is only productive when we use faith. And, given the immense and
potentially eternal impact, no search for happiness is complete without
a serious, honest consideration of god and eternity, including sincere
reflection on our own experiences, and those of people around us.
Truth is elusive. Virtue is challenging. Faith is difficult. Not knowing
is unpleasant. Suffering is hard. Effort and trust are risky. But, as difficult
as they are, they're a part of happiness. And misery, which they help avoid,
is far worse.
Chapter 8
A Guide to Misery
Happiness gives more than it takes, but it
does take. It demands sacrifice, self-control, and patience. Misery, on the
other hand, is as easy as falling. It avoids strain, investment, uncertainty,
faith, discomfort, loneliness, embarrassment, or even thought…temporarily.
Anyone can do it. Up front, it's fun and easy, and down the road when that
changes, just compensate by piling on more pleasure, right?
While simple enough for most to figure out on their own, included here
for your convenience is a simple guide to misery:
Give up (on happiness). It's easier. And, easier means better.
Give in. You know you want to. What does your conscience know, anyway?
Take whatever you want, whenever you want it, and don't give back. You
deserve it…somehow.
Think only of your own immediate gratification. You don't owe anything
to anyone—not even the ones who gave you everything you have.
Demand and expect perfect circumstances that never change. Life should
be easy. And suffering must be someone else's fault (most likely, someone
who loves you and is perfect and all-knowing).
Defer costs as long as possible—preferably until you're dead so someone
else can deal with them.
Procrastinate any real work. Life is short.
Don't bother progressing in any way. It's all pointless. Life is cosmically
accidental, and ends in empty nothingness, so do whatever you want. Why
work at something hard just to get better, then die?
Find the easiest path. Everyone else is doing it, which means it's right.
Lay back and let entropy, atrophy, and apathy do whatever they want to
do. What will be will be. It's fate—or something…
Wait for someone else to make you happy. Because that always works.
Forget the truth. It's all subjective anyway. You have your
own truth.
Assume you know everything. Nothing could possibly exist if you don't
know about it, and it probably won't exist until you
do know about it. And it will stop existing once you forget about it. Because,
that's just logic.
Assume your perception is always accurate, and your opinion is always
right (and more so than anyone else's).
Demand to be right. But then disconnect yourself from reality as much
as possible.
Believe only what you can see and already understand. Or, believe anything
sensational and popular and flattering and convenient.
Fight anyone who disagrees with you. Or smugly laugh at them, roll your
eyes, criticize, or condescend. It's sure to change their mind and prove
just how right you are.
Focus only on what you do well, and what others do poorly. It's a great
way to hide your insecurity.
Blame all your failings on circumstance, and others' on character. People
surely think you're perfect. Why surprise them?
If you notice a flaw in yourself, beat yourself up for it (but don't do
anything about it), then hide it by criticizing others for doing the same
thing. Offense is the best defense.
Hide who you are. You want people to like you, right?
Stay exactly as you are. Who cares what other people think?
Never ever love anyone. You might have to do or commit to something. And just think of all the pain your loneliness will prevent!
Never trust anyone. And it will probably help if they know you distrust
them.
Never help or try to understand anyone. But expect them to help and try
to understand you. Fair only matters if it's in your favor.
Expect people to change. But also stay the same—exactly when and how you
want them to.
Never stop to think. Only stop to stew, stress, dwell on frustrations,
and relive your miseries. It's probably productive.
Worry about everything, but only in a panicked, irrational, non-constructive
way that makes it harder to change anything.
Try to not enjoy or focus on anything you're currently doing. How will
you enjoy the future without stressing about it now (and also stressing
about the future when you get there)?
Ignore the future and disregard the past. Just live in the now. Learning
and preparation are for boring prudes.
Base your self worth on things you can't fully control—like appearance,
health, wealth, intelligence, occupation, fame, and public opinion.
If you ever find yourself beginning to slip into happiness, remind yourself
how much better others have it, of everything you don't have or can't do,
then blame it on someone—preferably a person who loves you.
When life is hard, assume you're the only person who has ever suffered,
and expect everyone to make it up to you. Then, when you do see someone
else suffer in the same way, pretend you were never in their shoes, let
them suffer alone, and blame them for it. Mocking them would probably help,
too.
Always find someone to blame. It has to be
someone's fault, and there's no way it could be
yours.
Be afraid (any subject will do). Best of all, be afraid of
everyone. But hide that fear with aggression and violence.
Trust all your fears, and doubt all your hopes. Better to be constantly
miserable than occasionally disappointed.
Take no risks. What if it doesn't work out? Or, take huge risks with very
little upside, because
that's real fun.
Make your life a series of increasingly less satisfying pursuits—basically,
immediate gratification and anything addictive. Historically, that has
worked out really well for everyone.
Fill your time with so many wants that you don't have any room for needs.
Where possible, make sure your wants conflict with other people's needs.
Every man for himself, and whoever dies with the most stuff…wins…something.
Above all, make sure your life is a ceaseless carnival of comfort, convenience,
self-indulgence, isolation, blissful ignorance, fear, anger, unfounded
self-assurance, and immediate reward.
Truth and virtue are easy to avoid. Just make the fastest, easiest, most
immediately gratifying decisions you can, and insulate yourself from reality
with extreme, biased, sensational, flattering theories and opinions. You'll
be miserable in no time. And what's more, you'll have helped provide suffering
for everyone around you!
–
It can be easier to recognize truth upside-down (one actual utility of
sarcasm). Artists flip drawings over to more clearly see and correct mistakes.
Proofreaders study passages backward to achieve better focus on parts of
a sentence their brain might otherwise have missed. Turning things around
can reveal absurdities in our thoughts and behaviors.
While misery isn't our goal, it
is a concerningly common result of our decisions. A closer look at what most
directly causes misery also shows the wisdom of the principles that lead
to happiness.
Pleasure and Fun
Pleasure keeps winding up next to misery, but to be fair, it isn't
inherently destructive. It's just not what we're actually looking for. We can be
submerged in pleasure and still feel empty and unsatisfied. We aren't born
fully understanding what happiness is, and won't until we actually experience
it. People who don't know what happiness is or how to achieve it understandably
reach for something similar. But pleasure is a fool's gold that usually
comes at a cost—sometimes a very high and even permanent one. Pleasure
doesn't satisfy the way happiness does, and it becomes less satisfying
with time. Until we learn what happiness is, we simply reach for even more
pleasure, and the cost grows. Eventually, you build up a deficit so great
that despair takes over.
We get off course when we assume that pleasant paths lead to pleasant
destinations. Happiness (like nearly all good things) requires effort,
investment, sacrifice, faith, struggle, and patience; even some empathy-generating
sadness and pain. It's the difficult path that makes us strong, resilient,
and empathetic—that takes us upward. The wisest choice is to pick the right
destination, then stick to whatever path leads to it. In the case of happiness, that
means not being led off course by pleasures (which in the old days were
referred to, very aptly, as "diversions"). You'll still find fun along
the way.
Some pleasure is good. In balance, it's constructive. It's frosting on
the cake—but it's not the cake. The most concerning issue with pleasure
is our tendency to let it replace and prevent actual happiness (like dessert
replacing dinner). That can be fixed by simply knowing and doing what it
takes to be happy and healthy
first. Priorities.
There's certainly such a thing as too much work, sacrifice, or suffering,
and it's common for us to end up on
that extreme. Wisdom helps us find the right balance.
For those who have no conscious goal or destination in mind, join the
rest of us in the pursuit of happiness.
–
At some point, everyone wonders
what the point of life is, but miserable people are more likely to wonder
if there's a point. That makes sense. If you're miserable, you
have missed the point. Life is growth. If you're progressing, you're becoming
happy, and have fulfilled the basic purpose of intelligent life. You may
be missing some information about the broader picture and might be curious
about it, but there's still a sense of peace and satisfaction. Misery is
destruction—the opposite of growth—so a miserable life truly doesn't make
sense. It's a fundamental contradiction. But it's misery that should end,
not life.
Misery usually
feels endless and inescapable, but it isn't (though it
is easier to avoid than to fix). Have hope that happiness is not only possible,
but certain, once you understand and comply with the necessary laws. You
may need help, but help is available. Happiness is real. Truth is the map.
Virtues are the keys. Suffering is part of
everyone's journey. Desire and effort and well-being are critical, and even in exceptional
circumstances you can hope for eventual, real, lasting happiness.
Epilogue
Imagine a happy world—one in which we're all reasonable, calm, and can
face reality head-on with curiosity and confidence, and where we're all
well, cared for, loving, and engaged in making life better for everyone.
Imagine yourself being happy, and surrounded by happy people who see all
others as equally valuable. Imagine everyone being in a constant state
of growth—learning more and becoming better every day, free and able to
contribute in unique and meaningful ways. Imagine never having to worry
about your needs, never having to fear crime or injustice or criticism,
and living with an assurance that you'll be supported in every challenge
that comes along. In other words, imagine a world full of truth and virtue.
It took decades of suffering and thought to learn what I've tried to condense
into just over 100 pages. As much as I love words, I can't find any that
express the value of these truths, or that fully illustrate how helpful
they could be to the world. I've intentionally separated myself from the
concepts, and tried to present them on their own, objectively and logically,
but they're more than just ideas. Try to think of a single problem the
world faces that couldn't be resolved or at least significantly improved
by united and serious emphasis on truth and virtue. Poverty, hunger, inequality,
extremism, conflict, pollution, disease, mental illness, broken families,
loneliness… They could all but disappear. That's absolutely idealistic—but also possible. Our inability to imagine it is largely what prevents it.
This book is meant as a personal guide (mostly for my children, who I think deserve to inherit what I've learned in many instances from them), but I hope you'll also recognize
it as a common ground for
humanity —every belief system, country, culture, and ideology. Is it really too
much to hope we can all recognize and agree on the value of truth, virtue,
and wellness? I hope not. This isn't religion or [rocket] science. And
if we can agree on that, then we have a place from which we can build.
We may look or act differently, but we're far more similar than separate,
and we all want the same thing: Happiness. It's not easy to find. If it
were, this book would be pointless. But, the growing challenge of identifying
truth, the fading expectation of virtue, widespread unwellness, and the
almost universal problem of misery show how poorly understood real happiness
is. The world as it currently stands is not a happy place. So, what is
it about humanity that prevents us from achieving something we all want?
Well, it's obviously not a lack of wanting. It's a lack of
knowing what we need to understand,
being what we need to be, and
doing what is required. So, for now, this book has a place. I hope for the day
when it's no longer needed. In the meantime, there's more to share—but it wouldn't
make sense without this foundation.
Like a message in a bottle, I've thrown this out to sea with the hope that the
right people will find it. Like every person who has ever sent a book off
into the world I hope it's brilliantly life-changing, but I'm [just barely]
grown-up enough to know that most who read this—whether it turns out to
be brilliant or not—will put it back on the shelf, walk away, and make
no significant change to their life. Change is hard. We're all a bit stubborn
about our thoughts and opinions, and are creatures of habit that by nature
find the most efficient way to survive. In other words, we do whatever
we've always done. But, we're also beings of exceptional intelligence
and infinite potential, who crave happiness—not just survival. My hope,
at the intersection of those two realities, is that we'll
do something. This is a map, so I clearly hope you'll follow it to the treasure at
the end. But, progress is good enough for now. Just take a step. Change
a little every day. Make an unusual effort.
Where do you start? Learn to love, recognize, and accept truth. Education.
Reading. New experiences. Trying to be observant, actively listening and
being open-minded and moderate, getting information from many sources,
bothering to verify it, and taking time to think and reflect. It's a marathon,
not a sprint, so focus on what you can sustain. Life prefers small, incremental
improvements to massive, sudden ones. Make learning a daily habit. Eventually,
that truth will add up and connect in surprising and important ways.
Pay attention to virtue. Identify the virtues you lack, and work on them.
Allow yourself to be inspired and fueled by the virtue in others. Change.
Feel. Listen to your conscience, which will generally tell you what you
need to know. Trust that virtue, though challenging, is worth the effort.
You may not be able to
escape the temptation to trade virtues for assets, but you
can (and must) ignore it. No asset is worth having that costs you your happiness.
Manage your well-being. Find routines that promote health and progress.
Be thoughtful about the complexity of your life. Pay attention to your
body and your thoughts. Be aware of your feelings. If your basic needs
are met and you still have something left to give, please do. The happiness
of billions is held back by inadequate resources, and your assets can help.
The more resources you possess, the more control (and therefore responsibility)
you have.
Miserable people are identified by their willingness to say and do what
is untrue and unkind. That they're unkind shows they're miserable, and
therefore wrong—in the most basic and objective way. It's impossible to
overstate the destruction caused by those who knowingly distort truth,
encourage us to abandon virtue, or promote conflict (which does both).
That's a direct attack on happiness, and is always for their personal gain.
For everyone's happiness—and to protect yourself—learn to recognize truth,
share it, and trust in the power and value of virtue. Trust, follow, and
imitate only those who are truthful and kind (to everyone).
A common myth says we all find happiness in our own way. That may simply
be people confusing happiness with survival, reducing the idea of happiness
to meaningful purpose, or just acknowledging that our paths and circumstances
are different. But, thankfully, happiness isn't that random. The process
of happiness is consistent and natural and universal. The target doesn't
move.
Everything that brings real happiness to you also facilitates the happiness
of others. Happy people naturally help and improve everything and everyone
within their reach, and the efforts and characteristics that lead to happiness
in the first place are equally constructive. When you multiply the power
of happiness by the number of people this world holds, it's easy to see
how it would solve the world's problems. Individual happiness is the best
solution to global misery.
We can't give happiness, but we can give love. We can support people in
their suffering, help them achieve well-being, and improve their circumstances
enough to place them back within reach of happiness. We can share what
we know, share what we have, and be an example of virtue. We can demonstrate
real happiness.
The moment we acknowledge happiness as the point of life, everything falls
cleanly into place: why we do what we do, the importance of truth, what
makes something right or wrong, good or bad… The course of action also
becomes clear. As individuals, it's to grow in truth and virtue. As parents,
teachers, or leaders, it's to promote truth and virtue (mostly by example).
As children, students, or citizens, it's to learn and be guided by truth
and virtue, and to require truth and virtue from those who lead us. Those
who make, interpret, and enforce law ought to do so with strict dedication
to truth and virtue. Every occupation, initiative, organization, and business
needs to be founded on truth and virtue. All the struggles of society could
be resolved, permanent peace achieved, and well-being ensured, but the
only way to get there is through the powerful unity that a shared understanding
of reality starts, and that love completes.
Happiness is real, and the laws that lead to it do work. This book is
a map that will point you in the right direction. I know, because these
principles—shared by other wise people—pointed me in the right direction. The difficult work ahead is up to you, but your
challenges can bring progress, and make success even more meaningful. The
reward is worth the struggle. Once you've found it, share it.
The cutting makes the statue, the blow forms the blade,
The furnace turns the clay to stone, the pressure casts the jade.
The venture makes the hero, and when the task is done,
It's polished soul, not polished ore, that proves the prize was won.
This chest you've found, and deep inside are riches to behold—
A treasure sought, a treasure won, beyond its weight in gold:
A being now of greater worth, refined, with heart and steel.
Now go and send some hungry soul to seek what I conceal.
The Chest With a Hundred Locks (Annotated)
I'd usually defend letting readers enjoy and digest a poem at their own
speed, taking time to extract and internalize each layer of metaphor as
they're ready for it. Forcibly excavating every possible nugget is a job
for literature students, and divulging the meaning of a poem is not unlike
explaining a joke. I'll admit that as a writer it's tempting to wait and
see what significance readers dredge up, because it has the potential to
make me look a bit more clever than I actually am. But, the purpose of
this book was to take something rarely and barely understood—and uniquely
important—and make it as clear as possible. Considering that, and our current,
intense desperation for happiness, I think it's time to speed things up
a bit and shine some light on valuables that might have been missed. So,
I hope you enjoyed the short-lived metaphors.
A treasure chest sat anchored far beneath a twisting tide;
Its siren song sang loud and strong of spoils held deep inside.
Through weary years I'd sought it out o'er seas of calm and storm,
While coral, clam, and barnacle disguised its ancient form.
The protagonist is each of us, searching for happiness (the treasure).
It can take many years to find, though it calls constantly to all of us.
It's not far away, but likely to only be found by those determined to find
it, and who recognize its value in spite of its disguised appearance (it
often looks boring, obvious, restrictive, old-fashioned, and unsensational).
This takes place at sea, which represents the variability and turbulence
of life.
Some seasons past, alone I'd sat and cursed an icy gale,
When a stranger's voice, though old, soon pulled me in with an earnest
tale
Of a roiling sea and a row toward shore, waves thrashing, tall and steep,
Then the ship broke, and the tide's grip tugged fast into the deep.
We all go through storms (challenges), but some are able to be happy in
spite of them, while others struggle. Those who find happiness usually
do so through [often many years of] difficult, painful, overwhelming experience
that takes them to places they wouldn't have chosen to go…
In waning light their eye caught sight of an object in the sand,
So against the churn this stranger fought, and seized it with a hand.
A chest they'd found—fixed firm by time—then they quickly rose for air,
But eyed the shore and marked the spot, to seek the treasure there.
but, it's in those depths of suffering that they look a bit closer, fight
a bit harder, and get their first glimpse of happiness. Importantly, happiness
doesn't move. It remains where it has always been, because it's based on
realities that don't change.
Outstretched they held a yellowed map, well worn from ocean faring,
Its sparse lines sketched where to find the shoreline and the bearing.
The chest, they said, held riches more than a single soul could spend,
So the map was mine, with a kindly nod, and I thanked my new-found friend.
The happy can't give happiness, but they can share their story, and the
time-tested truth (yellowed map) that led them to happiness. Truth is like
a map, in that it's simple and accurate, but only beneficial to those who
follow it. And happiness can't be exhausted. It only grows as it's shared. Real friends are those who share what they can to support the happiness of others.
Then time had past, as I rowed and dove, till pain gave way to pleasure,
And I found at last the blessed chest which held the ancient treasure.
That sturdy box, still mortared fast by crusted shells and rocks,
Had a rusty lid with a checkered grid—and a hundred simple locks.
We don't usually find happiness immediately, even if we stick to the truth,
but in the process of trying we do make progress and find some joy. Life
gets better. Ultimately, we get to where we need to be (the treasure is
fixed in place, so we have to come to it, where it is and will always be),
but getting to the chest isn't enough. Unlocking happiness isn't done by
simply knowing the truth, or doing certain things. It's reserved for those
who become a certain type of person. Each virtue helps unlock happiness.
There are many, and every one is important.
Back home I rowed that night, with empty hands and troubled head.
No key was shared with the map…though, perhaps, I could make each one
instead.
For a hundred dives I read each lock as long as lungs could stand,
And home I went, and months I spent molding key after key by hand.
It's confusing and frustrating to feel like you've done everything you
were supposed to do, and still aren't happy. You might doubt those who
pointed you in the right direction. However, it's a simple fact that they
can't give you virtue. They can't make you the kind of person you need
to become. But, you can. One by one, you can develop each virtue. They're
not complicated. You can figure them all out. It just takes time and effort.
Then I rowed and dove with cheer and hope and the heft of a hundred keys
To pull me straight to the chest where I sank on anxious hands and knees.
I swiftly worked, and jerked the lid when I'd turned the final locks,
And shimmering sand and bubbles swirled like gold dust ‘round the box.
Virtues give you confidence, hope, and strength. They lead you—even pull
you—directly to where happiness is. You will find yourself on hands and
knees, adequately humble, right where you need to be, and able to unlock
happiness.
But the chest was bare—no treasure there on its strangely polished base,
So I looked inside and all I saw was my hopeful, searching face.
Then a golden gleam ensnared my eye from the ancient, lifted lid—
A shining script, a gilded verse…the gift the old box hid:
Happiness isn't wealth. It isn't fame or reputation or influence. It's
not beauty or strength, or perfect health. It might not contain any of
the things you imagined it would, or thought you wanted. Hence the empty
chest. Happiness is a reflection and clear understanding of who you are
and the progress you've made (the polished insides). It's feeling your
own growth.
"The cutting makes the statue, the blow forms the blade,
The furnace turns the clay to stone, the pressure casts the jade.
The venture makes the hero, and when the task is done,
It's polished soul, not polished ore, that proves the prize was won.
We hate the pain and struggle we think holds us back from the happiness
we want. But, it's the pain, the suffering, the sadness, the struggle,
and the hard-won experience (the cutting, the blow, the furnace, the pressure,
and the venture) that turns us into something exceptional—something beautiful,
useful, durable, and valuable (statue, blade, stone, and jade). It's what
you are (polished soul), not what you have (polished ore) that produces
happiness.
This chest you've found, and deep inside are riches to behold—
A treasure sought, a treasure won, beyond its weight in gold:
A being now of greater worth, refined, with heart and steel.
Now go and send some hungry soul to seek what I conceal."
The reward of all that difficulty—if we respond properly to it—is a powerful
and lasting happiness, stemming from changes deep within us (understanding
and virtue). That's worth more than anything else we could have wanted.
It's what every hungry soul actually wants, whether or not they realize
it. The best thing we can do is guide them in the right direction.
A treasure chest with a hundred locks awaits below the sea,
It's riches there for all who seek the wealth it brings to me.
So now I wait, and watch, and hope for souls who thirst for more,
A map to share, to guide them where the chest's not far from shore.
Happiness is waiting for everyone, right where it always was and will
always be. The requirements are the same for everyone. There's no limit
to how many people can enjoy it, so once you've found it yourself, guide
the seeking souls to it. It's not far out of reach—they just need to know
where and how to look.
–
Most metaphors break when stretched too far, and these are no exception.Happy
people aren't always old. Catastrophe isn't always necessary to discover
happiness. Happiness isn't only unlocked when we have every last virtue—it
grows incrementally as we progress and gain knowledge. When unlocked, it's
not in any way disappointing (by then we understand what it won't contain).
So, take this poem for what it was meant to be, and it may help you find
what you're looking for.